United States – Paraguay: a 4-1 that flatters the half the U.S. surrendered without Pulisic

The most important thing Mauricio Pochettino did on Friday night did not produce a goal. It removed one. At half-time, with the United States 3-0 up and playing the most fluent football of his tenure, the coach took Christian Pulisic off and sent the evening in two directions at once. The final score, 4-1, reads like a procession. It was nothing of the sort. It was two teams in the same shirt, divided by a single substitution — and the gap between them is the real story of the United States’ World Cup opener in Los Angeles.

For 45 minutes the hosts were a machine, and the machine had a design. Tyler Adams and Weston McKennie anchored a double pivot; the full-backs climbed; and Pulisic was handed the space between Paraguay’s lines to do as he pleased. Everything routed through him. The opener, in the seventh minute, was the blueprint in miniature: Pulisic split two defenders, the ball skidded across the face of goal by way of McKennie and off the despairing Damián Bobadilla into his own net. Gustavo Alfaro had built Paraguay as a low, stubborn, clean-sheet side. Inside seven minutes its last line had been walked straight through.

Recommended ReadingAmerica has spent a decade calling this its best soccer team ever — a home World Cup is where the promise comes due

What followed only sharpened the point. Folarin Balogun’s first, on the half-hour, came from a Pulisic cross that left the striker unattended in the centre to finish; his second, on the stroke of half-time, was a sumptuous solo strike into the top corner, one shift of the feet and a shot clocked at 61 mph. A third Balogun effort was chalked off for offside — the by-product of a deliberately high line Paraguay never solved. Seventy-five per cent possession, eight shots to two, four on target to none. Andrés Cantor called it the best 45 minutes of the Pochettino era, and the scoreboard did not argue.

Then Pochettino unplugged it. Pulisic — magnificent, but with a long tournament ahead and a body worth protecting — did not reappear; Sebastian Berhalter came on in his place. The connective tissue went with him. The United States could no longer break a line, because the man who broke lines was on the bench, and McKennie’s surges lost the runner who fed them. Possession drained away, the stadium that had shaken in the first half fell quiet, and Paraguay, suddenly given air, grew into the game. Adams’ booking just before the hour was the tell of a side now chasing the contest rather than dictating it.

The symmetry was almost too neat. Bobadilla, scorer of the own goal, had been withdrawn for Maurício — and it was Maurício who slid in Julio Enciso’s ball over the top in the 73rd minute to make it 3-1. A team that had been untouchable for 45 minutes had, for the next 30, looked like one defending an advantage it no longer fully controlled.

Giovanni Reyna restored the gloss in the 98th minute, curling a shot inside the far post with the outside of his boot — the last kick of the night, and a beautiful one. But that was a moment of individual quality, not the system rebooting. By then the United States were minding a lead rather than imposing a shape, and the second half had quietly belonged to Paraguay.

None of which erases the brilliance of the first half. A 4-1 in a World Cup opener — the country’s first multi-goal win at the tournament in 24 years — is a statement on home soil, and the first-half football was genuinely thrilling. But a column has to ask what the night proved, and the answer cuts both ways. Pochettino has built a team that, with Pulisic operating between the lines, can dismantle a well-drilled South American side at will. He has also built one that, without him, could not hold the ball for fifteen minutes against opponents who simply pushed up.

That matters beyond the aesthetics. In a Group D that also holds Turkey and Australia, goal difference is the first tiebreaker after head-to-head, and the goal Pochettino’s caution allowed could yet decide whether the United States finish first or second — and which knockout opponent that buys them. The deeper question is the one the knockout rounds will eventually pose in earnest: when a manager must rest his best player, or loses him, does the design survive the absence? On Friday it did not. The best 45 minutes of the Pochettino era and the most revealing 45 arrived in the same match — and only one of them will travel.

Tags: wc26, 2026 FIFA World Cup, Group D, Paraguay, United States

More Like This

World Cup 2026, Group D: USA favoured, but Güler’s Turkey won’t agree

Uruguay won a century by refusing to lose — Bielsa wants them to stop waiting and start hunting

Mexico – South Africa: Raúl Jiménez’s wait ends, but a 2-0 over nine men settles nothing

Canada – Bosnia & Herzegovina: a historic first point that should have been three

South Korea – Czechia: the night Korea learned to win without Son Heung-min

France don’t need the ball to win the World Cup — they need you to drop it