Dog films built on W. Bruce Cameron’s novels have trained audiences to brace for a goodbye, so the final scene of A Dog’s Perfect Christmas lands as a quiet reversal. The old basset hound Winstead, voiced by Thomas Haden Church, narrates the entire film; then, in its last moments, the corgi puppy Ruby speaks. The stray the story opens on, abandoned at the side of a road, ends it with a voice of her own.

That handover is the film’s thesis. Winstead insists throughout that Ruby keeps bringing new people into the pack, and the ending, as recaps from The Viewer’s Perspective and Brazil’s GameOverDrive lay out, proves him right: the Goss family’s Christmas is repaired not by a miracle but by people finally making decisions they had avoided.

Does Juliana survive?

Yes, but not at home. Juliana’s kidney infection spreads into organ failure and a medically induced coma; she wakes with acute flaccid paralysis and rehabilitation ahead. So Christmas Eve comes to the hospital, in a room the nurses lend them, still decorated from a gala the night before. Winstead and Ruby get in after Sander pretends to be blind.

The scene’s most concrete gesture belongs to Hunter (Milo Ventimiglia). Offered the vice-president job by his boss, Mrs. O’Brien, he turns it down for consulting work from home, so Juliana can return to the law career she gave up for the twins. It answers her complaint before she fell ill: permission to go back to work meant nothing while the shopping, housekeeping and laundry still fell to her. The happy ending is a renegotiated household.

Barbara’s note and the red cardinal

For Sander (Dennis Quaid), the turning point is a piece of paper. Winstead keeps pulling at a book in Sander’s bedroom until he looks inside and finds a note from his late wife, Barbara, written when she knew she was dying: she did not want her death to become the end of his life, and asks him to open his heart and find love again. That permission lets him pursue Claire (Mary Steenburgen) without treating it as a betrayal.

Winstead saw a red cardinal outside the house the day Barbara died and has linked the bird to her ever since. When one appears as Sander gives Claire her Christmas present, Claire explains the belief that cardinals carry the souls of loved ones who have died. GameOverDrive reads it as acceptance and continuity, not a supernatural event. Winstead has a simpler reading: the cardinal wants Claire in the pack.

Ello (Brooke Lena Johnson) ends up with Sean (Ethan Loomis), Mrs. O’Brien’s son, after they swap a signed Wayne Gretzky book and a letter from the skater Meryl Davis.

The adaptation also changed its dogs: in Cameron’s 2020 novel, Winstead is a wolfhound and Ruby is not a corgi, according to The Cinemaholic. Director Cathryn Michon chose a basset hound and a corgi for the screen. Netflix released the film on November 4.

Which is why hearing Ruby at last outweighs any speech in the film. Winstead’s story ends with the humans choosing the life they still have, and with the puppy he watched being abandoned finally speaking for herself.

Tags: Netflix, Dennis Quaid, Thomas Haden Church, A Dog’s Perfect Christmas, ending explained, Mary Steenburgen, Milo Ventimiglia

A Dog’s Perfect Christmas ending explained: why the last word goes to Ruby, not Winstead

Does Juliana survive?

Barbara’s note and the red cardinal

More Like This

Oyelowo lends ‘Selma’ gravitas to Hathaway’s Indiana cycling underdog drama ‘Little Five’

Warner Bros film chiefs Michael De Luca and Pamela Abdy are out as Skydance backs Paramount’s team

My Dearest Assassin on Netflix: raised by an assassin family, never trained as one

Larry David sizes up Obama’s tan suit: “prettay good… prettay… prettay… prettay… prettay good”

In ‘Affection,’ Jessica Rothe can’t remember the husband who insists he is hers

Nicola Coughlan’s Pegeen is McLaughlin’s bet that Synge stays combustible on a cinema screen

Discussion