Gaming

GTA 6 Reviews Hit 99 on Metacritic, With a Warning About the First 25 Hours

Adrian Kessler
Add us on Google

The reviews for Grand Theft Auto VI are in, and the question that hung over Rockstar for years has been answered with something close to unanimity. Critics are not merely positive. They are lining up behind a verdict usually reserved for games that get remembered as turning points, and the aggregate places this one among the best-reviewed releases the medium has produced.

What a single score cannot carry is the detail written inside those reviews, and that detail is what matters to anyone about to spend launch night in Vice City. Read past the perfect marks and the same pieces describe a long, guided opening, a structure that will not let you replay story missions, and a technical picture that two critics on the same console do not describe the same way.

YouTube video

A near-perfect score, and a dispute over the record

Metacritic lists GTA 6 at 99, with every one of its critic reviews counted as positive and none as mixed. GameSpot says that ties the 1998 Ocarina of Time for the highest aggregate the site has ever recorded. The Verge describes it as having passed Nintendo‘s classic. The outlets do not agree on the record, only on the size of it.

The perfect marks came from GameSpot, IGN, Game Informer and Destructoid, with five out of five from The Guardian, Eurogamer and Bloomberg. IGN’s Luke Reilly calls it the single most impressive video game he has ever played. Bloomberg’s Jason Schreier reduces it to a formula: a lot of money, time and talented people. Most of the praise lands on two things, a world that reacts to the player and the relationship between Jason and Lucia.

Rockstar knows that second part is a gamble. Rob Nelson, producer on the game and co-head of Rockstar North, told The Verge that the romance is a real change for the series, and that players can still play it the old way and reject all of it.

The warning about the opening

The sharpest dissent comes from Screenhub, which still gave the game four stars. Alice Clarke writes that she spent the first dozen hours completely bored, describing the first chapter as a Good Boyfriend Simulator with few chances for mischief. By her account the game became the GTA she expected around Chapter Three, roughly 25 hours in. She reached Chapter Four at 47 hours, and the main story took her a little over 70.

Her tone is the outlier. Her description is not. Eurogamer’s five-star review uses kinder words for the same structure: the game is stratified, to borrow Rockstar’s term, and there is progression to get through before what feels like the true GTA 6 reveals itself. Chris Tapsell also notes a mid-game narrative sag, built around side stories that feel a little throwaway. For a player who bought GTA for chaos, the first evenings may feel like a different game.

No replays, fifteen save slots

Eurogamer flags a design choice that could matter more over time. GTA 6 drops mission replay, which Tapsell says might prove controversial, and offers 15 save slots for anyone who wants to return to a favourite set piece. Screenhub adds a daily routine of feeding and training Jason and Lucia to keep them in shape, a loop Clarke says she resented.

Two reviewers, one console, two frame rates

The technical picture is less settled than the score suggests. Eurogamer says the game runs at 30 frames per second even on PS5 Pro, with frame pacing good enough that it feels smoother than the number implies. Screenhub, also on PS5 Pro, says it consistently hit 60 and suspects Rockstar specifies 30 to cover itself. Neither review describes a measurement tool, so the answer belongs to dedicated technical analysis, not to the review embargo.

The platform split matters too. Metacritic treats PS5 as the lead platform, with more than 140 reviews filed there against 14 on Xbox Series X. Rockstar’s own site labels PS5 as the place the game plays best. Eurogamer says how the game fares on other consoles, particularly the Xbox Series S, will be worth considering.

Price, platforms and launch

GTA 6 launches on November 19 on PS5 and Xbox Series X|S, at $80 for the Standard Edition and $100 for the Ultimate Edition. It unlocks region by region at midnight, and GameSpot reports it is already playable in New Zealand and Australia. There is no PC version at launch; analysts expect one in 2027, according to GameSpot, which also reports Take-Two shares rose close to 7% in pre-market trading after the reviews landed.

Only 14 of the reviews Metacritic counts were filed on Xbox, and the Xbox Series S is the console a five-star review left as an open question.

Tags: , , , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.