Pelé spent the months before the World Cup in Mexico telling people he was finished. He was not yet thirty, but a brutal tournament four years earlier — where defenders had kicked him out of the competition while referees looked the other way — had convinced him his body owed football nothing more. He had said, more than once and in public, that he would never play for the national team again. The man the planet was about to crown the greatest footballer alive walked toward the most celebrated triumph in the sport’s history carrying a doubt the highlight reels would quietly erase.

Brazil ’70: The Third Star is built in the space between that doubt and the gold that followed. The team Brazil took to Mexico is remembered as the most complete side ever assembled — the one whose fourth goal against Italy, finished by a captain arriving from nowhere, is still played to children as evidence of what the game can be. Netflix’s series is far less interested in the result than in the question of who got to keep it. The country that produced this team was, by then, four years into a military dictatorship that censored its newspapers, exiled its musicians and tortured its dissidents. The regime understood at once that a third world title was the most persuasive advertisement it could ever run. The players won the tournament. The generals collected the dividend.

That is the argument the show keeps returning to, and it is braver than a victory lap. The win belongs, in the national memory, to everyone — it is the warmest thing modern Brazil agrees on. The series declines to leave it there. It stages the joy and then asks, without raising its voice, what the joy was used for, and it manages this without the lecture that usually sinks films about football and politics. The marches, the anthem, the slogan stamped over the goals — Pra Frente Brasil, forward Brazil — sit in the frame as weather rather than thesis.

The decision to dramatize rather than document is the series’ most consequential one. There is no shortage of footage from Mexico; it was the first World Cup broadcast in colour, and the goals survive in pristine, endlessly re-shown clips. What does not exist is a camera in the rooms where the story actually turned. Saldanha arguing with the federation. Pelé deciding, privately, whether to stay. The federation deciding, less privately, that a communist could not be allowed to lead the nation’s team into the regime’s showcase. To reach those rooms you cannot edit archive. You have to build them and cast actors into them.

Rodrigo Santoro, the most internationally recognized face in the production, plays not Pelé but João Saldanha — the sportswriter and declared communist who assembled the squad, qualified it without losing a match, contradicted the regime in print, and was removed from the job before the tournament he had built. Casting the marquee actor as the man who got fired, rather than as the icon who lifted the cup, tells you where the show’s centre of gravity sits. Bruno Mazzeo plays Mário Zagallo, the careful professional who inherited both the team and the credit, and who spent the half-century since fielding the question of how much of the triumph was actually his. Lucas Agrícola’s Pelé moves through all of it as a man auditing his own future, not a monument receiving tribute.

Saldanha’s story alone could carry a series. He was a newspaperman with no coaching badges and a Communist Party card, handed the most scrutinized job in the country, who answered by qualifying Brazil with a perfect record and then feuding in public with everyone from club managers to the president. The official reason given for his dismissal was erratic conduct; the unofficial one, which the series leans into, was that the dictatorship could not march a self-described revolutionary at the head of its parade. He was gone within months of qualifying, and the team he had chosen went on to win without him.

When the football arrives, it is shot in the realist register of O2 Filmes, the house behind City of God, so the matches read as sweat and altitude and collision rather than reverent slow motion. The series is unusually attentive to the physical price of the legend. Tostão played the tournament after surgery for a detached retina, one eye barely trusted. Gérson ran the midfield through a chain of cigarettes. Everyone laboured in the thin Mexican air that left European sides gasping. Quico Meirelles and the brothers Paulo and Pedro Morelli keep the ensemble human-scaled, so the famous men read as tired, frightened, funny professionals rather than statues.

That human scale is what lets the political layer land without sermonizing. A country was being told it was fine — broadcast in colour, scored to a winning team — by men working hard to make sure it could not say otherwise. The series never itemizes the regime’s crimes; it simply keeps the cost in the same frame as the celebration. The third star rose over a nation that had been instructed to look forward and not behind, and the show lets the viewer feel both the genuine euphoria and the use to which it was put.

This is the contract the series makes with its audience, and it is a risky one. Viewers come for the most beloved highlight reel in the sport — the yellow shirts, the Carlos Alberto goal, the warmth of a memory that even people born long after have inherited. What the show delivers alongside that is the uncomfortable backstage: the firing, the doubt, the propaganda. A lesser production would have served the nostalgia and skipped the asterisk. Brazil ’70: The Third Star insists on both, and bets that the football is more moving, not less, once you know what surrounded it.

There is a reason a Brazilian production is staging this now rather than treating the win as settled nostalgia. It is the country’s most sacred shared memory and also the dictatorship’s most effective piece of propaganda, and Brazil has never fully reconciled the two. To reopen it for a global platform, in the build-up to another World Cup summer, is to ask whether a nation can love its team without laundering the men who exploited it. That the question is being posed inside a Netflix prestige drama — the same lane that carried Senna to the world — is its own small story about who gets to tell national myths and on whose platform.

What the third star could never settle is whose it was. The eleven men on the pitch earned it with detached retinas and aching knees and a coach sacrificed to politics; the dictatorship spent the years afterward wearing it like a sash it had been awarded. Brazil ’70: The Third Star puts both claims on the screen and, to its credit, hands the trophy cleanly to neither.

Brazil ’70: The Third Star premieres May 29 on Netflix as a six-episode limited series, produced in partnership with O2 Filmes and created by Naná Xavier and Rafael Dornellas. The cast includes Lucas Agrícola as Pelé, Rodrigo Santoro as João Saldanha, Bruno Mazzeo as Mário Zagallo, Ravel Andrade as Tostão, Caio Cabral as Carlos Alberto, Gui Ferraz as Jairzinho and Fillipe Soutto as Gérson, directed by Paulo Morelli, Pedro Morelli and Quico Meirelles.

Brazil ’70: The Third Star — Netflix reopens the dressing room behind a sacked coach and a doubting Pelé

More Like This

James. on Netflix opens with Colombia’s No. 10 saying he has failed more than he has won

Rafa on Netflix is less about 22 Grand Slams than the body that paid for them

Untold UK: Liverpool’s Miracle of Istanbul — Netflix reopens the half-time door 21 years later

‘The Fight for Justice: Paolo Guerrero’ – A Netflix Series on Sports, Drugs and “Football”

Untold: Jail Blazers on Netflix asks who wrote the verdict before the trial

Álex Pina, the architect of a heist that refuses to end

Discussion