Music

Carrie Hope Fletcher, the untrained West End singer with her own audience

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Carrie Hope Fletcher
BornOctober 22, 1992
Harrow, London, England
OccupationSinger, stage actress
Awards4 WhatsOnStage

Carrie Hope Fletcher found her next show by scrolling. The folk musical Ballad Lines, built from Scottish, Irish and Appalachian ballads and played by an all-female band, reached her through social media while it was running at Southwark Playhouse, and she remembers thinking, “I want to be in a show like that!” Next spring she will lead it at The Other Palace in London. It is a fitting way in for a singer whose own audience found her through a screen long before any producer put her name above a title.

Fletcher never went to drama school. She learned the West End from the inside, as a child in the wings of Les Mis and Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, and she learned an audience from a webcam, posting songs and video diaries to a channel called ItsWayPastMyBedTime. That double apprenticeship explains most of what followed: a voice trained by eight shows a week, and a following that buys tickets for her rather than for the show on the poster. The open question of her career is how far that following will go once she leaves the titles it already knows.

She was born on 22 October 1992 and grew up in South Harrow, in north-west London, the younger sister of Tom Fletcher, who went on to co-found the pop band McFly. At seven she was cast as young Éponine in Les Mis. In 2002 she joined the original London cast of Chitty Chitty Bang Bang as Jemima, and two years later she played Jane Banks in Mary Poppins. She started her YouTube channel in 2011. It passed half a million subscribers, and its most watched video is still a performance of McFly’s “Love Is on the Radio” with her brother.

The adult break came in June 2013, when she replaced Danielle Hope as Éponine at the Queen’s Theatre. She held the role, with one interruption, until February 2016 and left as the longest-running Éponine in the London production’s history, having picked up a WhatsOnStage Award for best takeover in a role along the way. She is the only British actress to have played the young Éponine, the grown one and, later, Fantine in the same show. The interruption was Jeff Wayne’s The War of the Worlds, an arena tour in which she sang Beth opposite Jason Donovan.

YouTube video

Then came the parts that made her a lead. She played Wednesday in the UK tour of The Addams Family in 2017 and Veronica Sawyer in the original West End production of Heathers the following year, a show that moved from The Other Palace to the Theatre Royal Haymarket. Both roles won her WhatsOnStage Awards, which the public votes for, a detail that matters more than it seems. In March 2018 she released her first solo album, When the Curtain Falls, a set of musical-theatre songs that reached the UK top 20 and was launched with concerts at Cadogan Hall.

Andrew Lloyd Webber then handed her a role to originate. His Cinderella, delayed by the pandemic, opened at the Gillian Lynne Theatre in August 2021 and brought Fletcher another WhatsOnStage Award for best actress in a musical. Its cast album, on which she is a credited soloist, was nominated for the Grammy for best musical theater album, and so was the recording of the 2019 Les Mis staged concert at the Gielgud Theatre, where she returned to the show as Fantine. Neither won.

The ending of Cinderella is the part of her career she has spoken about most bluntly. On 1 May 2022 the producers announced that the show would close in June, eight months earlier than planned, and Fletcher, who was not on stage that day, heard the news second-hand. “I don’t think I have the words. And if I did I would probably be advised not to say them,” she wrote. Lloyd Webber later described the production as a costly mistake and took it to Broadway with a new name and a new cast. Months later she told Variety she had not heard from him since: “not even an apology – an apology would have been lovely – but an acknowledgement.” The episode showed the limit of her kind of fame. A fanbase can fill a theatre night after night and still give a performer no say when a producer decides the show is over.

YouTube video

There is a quieter criticism, and it concerns the music. After a quarter of a century on stage her recorded catalogue is slim: one solo album of other people’s songs, a handful of self-released singles such as “Running Through Rivers”, and cast recordings. Her concert tours lean on her own story as much as on her repertoire. Reviewing the first of them, An Open Book, at the London Palladium in 2023, TheatreMonkey found that a show billed as a concert tour played more like a one-woman jukebox musical about her life. Nobody doubts the voice. What she does with it outside somebody else’s score has yet to be settled.

She has spent the years since moving from stage to stage. She did her first straight play in 2022, as Grusha in Brecht’s The Caucasian Chalk Circle at the Rose Theatre, married the actor Joel Montague at Gretna Green in February 2023 and had a daughter the following year. In 2025 she toured the UK and Ireland in the title role of Calamity Jane, a revival that several critics said she carried, then spent Christmas at the Aldwych Theatre as Jovie in Elf, opposite Montague as Buddy, the first production the couple had shared. From March 2026 she played Jenna in a UK and Ireland tour of Waitress, a run extended as more cities were added, until her final performance at the end of September.

October brought The Ghost Light Tour, thirteen concerts staged mostly in cathedrals, from Lichfield to Portsmouth, with a London night at Cadogan Hall. She mixed her repertoire and new arrangements with stories about the theatres she has worked in and the spirits said to haunt their wings. She has kept writing too: her first book, All I Know Now, topped the Sunday Times bestseller list in 2015, and novels such as On the Other Side followed, along with the children’s books of The Double Trouble Society.

Ballad Lines runs at The Other Palace, the theatre where Heathers first opened, from 11 April to 4 July 2027, a twelve-week season of Finn Anderson’s songs in Tania Azevedo’s staging, with Fletcher as Sarah. For the first time in years she will be singing a score that most of her audience does not already know by heart. If her followers turn up for ballads they have never heard, simply because she is the one singing them, that will say more about her pull than any award has.

Tags: , , , , , Carrie Hope Fletcher

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.