Music

Jennifer Nettles, the Sugarland singer who keeps leaving Nashville and keeps coming back

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Jennifer Nettles
Jennifer Nettles
Photo: Craig ONeal / CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
BornSeptember 12, 1974
Douglas, Georgia, United States
OccupationSinger-songwriter
Known forHarriet, The Exorcist: Believer, Heartland
Awards3 Grammy · 2 CMA · ACM · CMT Equal Play · Emmy

In Netflix‘s Heartland, Jessica Chastain plays a faded country star who comes out of hiding to look for her missing niece in Nashville, and one of the people she turns to is an old rival. That rival, Winnie Jo Lean, is played by Jennifer Nettles. When the two women finally sing together on screen, Chastain has said, it was Nettles who gave her the confidence to do it. “Nobody sounds like Jennifer Nettles,” she told PEOPLE.

The casting is a quiet joke on anyone who has tried to file Nettles in one drawer. She is the voice of Sugarland, the duo that filled country radio with number ones for most of a decade. She has also been Roxie Hart on Broadway and the dead matriarch of HBO’s televangelist satire The Righteous Gemstones, and this summer she opened a musical about a poisoner that she wrote herself. Her career keeps asking whether a singer Nashville made can keep walking out of Nashville without losing the thing that made her worth hearing.

Douglas, Georgia, and the Atlanta coffeehouse years

Jennifer Odessa Nettles was born on September 12, 1974, in Douglas, a small town in south Georgia, and learned to perform in a Southern Baptist church and the Georgia 4-H touring troupe Clovers & Company. At Agnes Scott College in Decatur she studied Spanish and anthropology, graduating in 1997, and formed Soul Miner’s Daughter with the guitarist Cory Jones. The pair made two albums, The Sacred and Profane and Hallelujah, and played the Atlanta date of Lilith Fair in 1999.

The Jennifer Nettles Band came next, working the folk-rock rooms around Atlanta, above all Eddie’s Attic in Decatur, where she crossed paths with Kristian Bush, then half of the duo Billy Pilgrim, and the songwriter Kristen Hall. In 2002 the three of them formed Sugarland.

The Sugarland years

Their debut, Twice the Speed of Life (2004), came out on Mercury Nashville. Its first single, Baby Girl, written as letters home from a broke young musician, stalled at number two on the country chart but set the longest chart run of the SoundScan era. The album sold three million copies. Nettles also sang on Bon Jovi’s Who Says You Can’t Go Home, which took a New Jersey rock band to number one on the country chart and won her a first Grammy.

YouTube video

Hall left at the end of 2005, and the duo turned out to be bigger than the trio. Enjoy the Ride (2006) sold 211,000 copies in its first week and produced the number ones Want To and Settlin’. Its fourth single, Stay, was the first Sugarland song Nettles wrote alone, sung by the other woman in an affair who ends by sending her married lover home. It won Song of the Year at the CMA and ACM awards, then two Grammys. Love on the Inside (2008) became their first number one country album. The Incredible Machine (2010), a record that borrowed openly from OMD and Peter Gabriel, opened at number one on the Billboard 200. Sugarland won the CMA’s Vocal Duo of the Year five times in a row, from 2007 to 2011.

The night in Indianapolis

The defining crisis of the band’s career had nothing to do with a record. On August 13, 2011, minutes before Sugarland was due on stage at the Indiana State Fair, a gust of about 59 mph brought the temporary stage roof down onto the crowd. Seven people died and dozens were injured. Investigators later established that the fair’s executive director had wanted to delay the show because of the forecast, and that Sugarland’s managers, who knew rain was coming but not the wind and hail in the warnings, preferred to start on schedule. The engineering report blamed rigging that could never have held in that wind.

It is the one chapter the duo’s sunny public image cannot absorb. Sugarland played a free benefit concert for the victims and went on hiatus the following year. In 2014 the band was among the defendants in a $50 million settlement, with the State of Indiana paying $11 million and Live Nation, Sugarland and other parties covering the rest.

Solo records, Broadway and a dead televangelist’s wife

On her own, Nettles made That Girl (2014) with Rick Rubin producing; it entered the country albums chart at number one and the Billboard 200 at number five. Playing with Fire followed on Big Machine in 2016, along with a Christmas album, To Celebrate Christmas. Acting arrived in parallel. In 2015 she played Roxie Hart in Chicago on Broadway and Dolly Parton‘s mother in an NBC television film. Later came a limited run as Jenna in Waitress on Broadway in 2021 and a frightened mother in The Exorcist: Believer. Since 2019 she has been Aimee-Leigh Gemstone, the late matriarch seen in flashbacks in Danny McBride’s The Righteous Gemstones, where her duet Misbehavin’ with Walton Goggins went viral on its own.

Sugarland came back at the CMA Awards in 2017. Bigger (2018) included Babe, a Taylor Swift co-write with Swift on vocals and the first Sugarland recording that neither Nettles nor Bush had written. In 2021 she released Always Like New, an album of Broadway songs, on Concord.

YouTube video

The dress and the argument with radio

At the 2019 CMA Awards, Nettles arrived in a Christian Siriano gown whose train carried a hand-painted demand to country radio, an expletive included, to play women’s records, with “equal play” lettered on the back. CMT handed her its first Equal Play Award the following year. The argument had a personal edge. Her solo singles had never climbed higher than number 24 on the country chart, while the same voice, paired with a man in Sugarland, had collected a run of number ones.

Poison, Netflix and a twenty-year-old album

This year put all of those identities on stage at once. In July, Giulia: The Poison Queen of Palermo opened at the Perelman Performing Arts Center in New York, directed by Mary Zimmerman, with Nettles credited for the book, music and lyrics and starring as Giulia Tofana, the seventeenth-century Italian poisoner said to have supplied women desperate to escape their husbands. The reviews split along a clear line. TheaterMania called her performance “game, charismatic, and immensely entertaining” but found the book “too unfocused”; more than one critic reached for Sweeney Todd as the comparison the show could not shake.

Heartland, written and directed by Shana Feste, reached Netflix on November 13, with Nettles and Chastain covering Hailey Whitters’s song Heartland as the title track. Sugarland, meanwhile, is out on the Ride or Die Tour, 26 American dates marking two decades of Enjoy the Ride and the duo’s first headlining run since 2018, after a 2024 single with Little Big Town and the EP There Goes the Neighborhood.

Nettles married Justin Miller, who had appeared in the video for Want To, in 2011, and their son, Magnus, was born in December 2012. An earlier marriage, to Todd Van Sickle, ended in divorce in 2007.

The tour closes outside Dallas on November 21, and nothing new has been announced beyond it. The obvious unfinished business is Giulia: critics found plenty to admire and wanted the book rewritten, and the only person with the authority to rewrite it is the woman who sings the lead.

Selected Discography

  • That Girl (2014)
  • Playing With Fire (2016)
  • To Celebrate Christmas (2016)
  • Always Like New (2021)

Tags: , , Jennifer Nettles, , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.