Movies

Schindler’s List: the film where Steven Spielberg stopped pleasing audiences and started bearing witness

The black-and-white epic that won seven Oscars still feels less like a movie than an act of testimony.
Martha O'Hara

Schindler’s List is the film in which the most commercially successful director who ever lived put his gift for spectacle aside and used everything he had learned about moving an audience to do something far harder: to look. For two decades critics had treated Steven Spielberg as a magician of sensation, the man who built the blockbuster and then kept building it. This was the work that answered the question nobody thought he wanted to answer — what is all that craft actually for?

The story is true, and it resists easy uplift. Oskar Schindler is a German businessman and Nazi party member who arrives in occupied Krakow to get rich on the war, staffing an enamelware factory with Jewish workers because they are cheaper than Poles. He is a charmer, a bribe-payer, a man with no visible conscience. What the film tracks, scene by scene, is the slow and almost involuntary awakening of that conscience — until the profiteer is spending his entire fortune buying human beings off the transport lists, and roughly eleven hundred people are alive because of a man who set out only to make money.

YouTube video

A film shot in the past tense

Spielberg and cinematographer Janusz Kaminski shot almost the entire picture in stark black and white, handheld for long stretches, deliberately closer to newsreel and survivor memory than to the gloss of a studio epic. The decision does most of the moral work before a word is spoken: it strips the Holocaust of the warm, golden distance that colour and a swelling score would have lent it. John Williams understood this too, pulling his theme down to a single grieving violin, played by Itzhak Perlman, that never tells you how to feel so much as it sits with you while you do.

Into that monochrome comes the one image everyone remembers — a small girl in a red coat, wandering through the liquidation of the ghetto. It is the only sustained colour in the film, and it is not a flourish. It is the moment Schindler, watching from a hill, can no longer pretend the people below are an abstraction. When the red coat returns later, the audience has already learned to read it, and the film does not have to explain.

Three performances that refuse comfort

Liam Neeson plays Schindler as a closed door: all surface confidence, the change happening somewhere we are never quite allowed to see, which is exactly why it lands. Ben Kingsley, as the accountant Itzhak Stern, is the film’s quiet conscience and its bookkeeper of survival, every name on a list a small, exhausting victory. And Ralph Fiennes, in the role that made him, plays camp commandant Amon Goeth not as a monster but as something worse — an ordinary, self-pitying man who shoots prisoners from his balcony the way another might check the weather. Fiennes makes evil banal and casual, and that is the most frightening choice in the picture.

The weight of the real

The film comes from Thomas Keneally’s 1982 novel Schindler’s Ark, itself built on the testimony of survivors — above all Poldek Pfefferberg, one of the rescued, who spent decades trying to get the story told. Spielberg took no salary for the film; he has said he could not profit from it. With what it earned he founded what is now the USC Shoah Foundation, recording tens of thousands of survivor testimonies before the generation that lived it was gone. The picture, in other words, did not end when the credits rolled — it became an instrument for the thing it was about.

Schindler's List (1993)
Schindler’s List (1993)

Why it endures

Schindler’s List won seven Academy Awards, including Best Picture and the Best Director prize that had eluded Spielberg through a career of hits, along with three Golden Globes and a place, a decade later, in the United States National Film Registry. But the awards are the least interesting thing about it. What endures is the closing admission the film makes about its own hero — that he could have done more, that he is destroyed by the arithmetic of how many he did not save. In a medium that loves a clean rescue, Schindler’s List refuses one. It remains the rare film that treats remembering not as a comfort but as a duty, and asks the viewer to take it up.

Director

Steven Spielberg

Steven Spielberg

Cast

Tags: , , , , ,

Discussion

There are 0 comments.