Cybersecurity

Meta faces a UK fine of up to 10% of revenue over the risk checks behind Instagram Instants

Susan Hill
Add us on Google

Ofcom is investigating whether Meta assessed the risks of Instagram’s disappearing-photo feature for illegal content and for children before launch. Meta says it did, and that it briefed the regulator several times.

Britain’s online safety regulator wants to see the paperwork behind Instagram Instants. Ofcom has opened a formal investigation into whether Meta carried out the risk assessments the Online Safety Act requires before it switched the feature on, and the penalty for getting that wrong can reach 10% of the company’s qualifying worldwide revenue. Instants lets people take a photo inside Instagram and send it to close friends or mutual followers, who can look at it once before it disappears.

The case is less about whether disappearing photos are good or bad than about the order in which things happened. The law says a platform must think through the risks of a significant change before users get it, and put that analysis in writing. Ofcom is checking whether Meta did so for illegal content and for the risks to children. Meta says it did. The answer will show how much weight the UK’s safety-by-design rules carry when the company on the other side is one of the largest in the world.

What Instagram Instants is and how it works

Instants behaves more like BeReal or Snapchat than like the Instagram feed. Photos have to be taken in the moment with a single tap, uploads from the camera roll are blocked, and the only edit allowed is a line of text. Each photo stays available for 24 hours, and senders can keep a private archive of their own shots for up to a year. The feature sits inside Instagram’s direct messages and also comes as a standalone app, which Meta first tested in Spain and Italy before Instants reached Instagram on May 13, 2026.

For the people who use it, the appeal is easy to see. A picture that vanishes after one view feels casual and low-pressure among friends, closer to a glance than to a post. The same design leaves nothing behind for a parent, a moderator or the police to find later. That trade-off is exactly the kind the Online Safety Act asks platforms to weigh on paper before a launch, and it is the reason Ofcom has singled out this feature.

Instants also arrives late to an idea Snapchat built a business on. Snapchat launched in 2011 around photos that delete themselves, and Instagram has borrowed from it before, most visibly when it introduced Stories in 2016. BeReal, launched in 2020, added the push to post a spontaneous, unedited picture. Instants combines both habits inside an app with a far larger audience than either rival, which helps explain why Ofcom treats the launch as a significant change to the service rather than a routine update.

What Ofcom is investigating

The investigation, opened on Tuesday, October 6, rests on two provisions of the Online Safety Act 2023: sections 9(4) and 11(4). Together they require a provider to carry out further illegal-content and children’s risk assessments before it makes a significant change to the design or operation of its service. The legal question is whether Meta produced assessments for Instants that were “suitable and sufficient”, the standard the Act sets, before the feature went live.

The regulator frames its case around process as much as product. “Our online safety laws are clear – significant changes to platforms must be risk assessed before they’re launched,” said George Lusty, Ofcom’s director of enforcement. “Safety by design must be built in, not bolted on.” Lusty compared the duty to testing a new car before it goes on sale, and said the regulator will act where it has doubts about compliance. Earlier this year, Ofcom had warned the largest platforms that skipping a reassessment before a major change could lead to enforcement.

The investigation is at an early stage. Ofcom will first gather and study evidence. If it finds a likely breach, it issues a provisional decision, Meta gets to respond in full, and only then does a final ruling follow. Opening an investigation does not establish that Meta broke the law, and the regulator has set no deadline for reaching a conclusion.

Meta’s defence

Meta says the safeguards were in place from day one. According to the company, recipients cannot screenshot, reshare or forward an Instant, there is no public feed, and teen accounts get their protections automatically, including parental supervision tools. “We conducted a risk analysis and briefed Ofcom about this feature on a number of occasions before launching it,” a Meta spokesperson said, adding that the company takes its duties under the Act seriously and will cooperate with the investigation.

Those two positions do not have to contradict each other. Meta can have analysed the risks and briefed the regulator, and Ofcom can still conclude that the analysis fell short of what the law calls suitable and sufficient. Briefing a regulator is not the same as completing the formal assessment the Act describes, so the investigation will look at what Meta’s documents say, how thorough they were and when they were finished.

Some of the safeguards have obvious limits. Blocking screenshots does nothing to stop a recipient from photographing the screen with a second phone. Teen Accounts, which Instagram introduced in 2024 with stricter default settings and parental controls for under-18s, depend on the platform knowing a user’s real age. Neither point decides the case, which is about paperwork rather than proof of harm, but both show why a regulator would want to see the reasoning in writing.

The law behind the case

The Online Safety Act became law in October 2023, and its duties have come into force in stages. The illegal-content duties took effect in March 2025 and the child-protection duties in July 2025, so Instants launched with both sets of rules fully in force. Since October 2025, Ofcom has issued more than £7 million in fines against 11 providers under the Act, including £520,000 against 4chan over child protection failures.

The pressure on Meta in the UK predates this case. In May, Ofcom said Meta and other platforms had committed to additional protections for children in the UK after pressure from the regulator. Meta has also brought a separate legal case against Ofcom over parts of the Act, including the regulator’s information demands and the fees platforms must pay. The Molly Rose Foundation, the charity set up by the family of Molly Russell, has called for Meta to be held accountable. Molly Russell died in 2017 at the age of 14, and the coroner at her 2022 inquest concluded that the negative effects of online content had contributed to her death.

What a fine could mean for Meta

If Ofcom finds a breach, it can order Meta to comply or to put right any harm caused, and impose a fine of up to £18 million or 10% of qualifying worldwide revenue, whichever is greater. For a company of Meta’s size, the percentage is the figure that matters: Meta reported about $201 billion in revenue for 2025. Qualifying worldwide revenue is defined by the Act’s own rules and need not match the group total, so the real ceiling is uncertain, but any amount near that scale would dwarf the fines Ofcom has issued so far.

The case covers the UK only and has no direct effect on how Instants works in other countries, including Spain and Italy, where the standalone app was first tested. A finding against Meta would still be one of the clearest signals so far of how strictly Ofcom intends to enforce the rule that safety checks happen before a product reaches users rather than after problems surface.

Ofcom announced the investigation five months after Instants reached Instagram. The photos vanish after one view. The documents Meta says it prepared before launch are what Ofcom now wants to read, and the outcome will show whether a risk assessment under the Online Safety Act is a box to tick or a step that can cost a tech company a share of its revenue.

Tags: , , , , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.