Music

Stephen Sondheim, the songwriter whose flops became Broadway’s canon

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Stephen Sondheim
Stephen Sondheim
Photo: Gotfryd, Bernard, photographer / Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
BornMarch 22, 1930
New York City, New York, United States
DiedNovember 26, 2021 (91)
OccupationComposer and lyricist
Known forGlass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery, tick, tick… BOOM!, Camp
AwardsPulitzer Prize (shared) · Academy Award · Tony Award · Tony Award (lifetime achievement) · Grammy · Kennedy Center Honors · Presidential Medal of Freedom

Twice in his career, Stephen Sondheim watched a new musical of his close on Broadway before most of New York had a chance to see it. Anyone Can Whistle lasted nine performances. Merrily We Roll Along managed sixteen, and its collapse ended his partnership with the producer and director Hal Prince, the alliance that had given the American musical its most daring run of shows.

Both flops have since turned into repertoire. A Broadway revival of Merrily We Roll Along with Jonathan Groff, Daniel Radcliffe and Lindsay Mendez won the Tony for best revival, and Richard Linklater is filming the same story across two decades with Paul Mescal and Ben Platt. That reversal is the shape of Sondheim’s working life. For years critics called his songs too clever to hum. He kept writing them, for an audience that tended to show up after the reviews had been printed.

An afternoon at Hammerstein’s farm

Manhattan’s garment trade paid for his childhood. His father, Herbert, manufactured dresses, and his mother, Janet Fox, designed them. The boy, born on March 22, 1930, grew up comfortable and lonely, and when the marriage broke up around 1940 he moved with his mother to Bucks County, Pennsylvania. Their relationship stayed cold for the rest of her life. Sondheim later recounted that she once wrote to him that her only regret was having given birth to him.

The move put him a few miles from the farm of Oscar Hammerstein II, and the lyricist of Oklahoma! became his surrogate father and teacher. At fifteen, Sondheim handed him a school musical and asked to be judged as a professional. Hammerstein told him it was the worst thing he had ever read, then spent the afternoon explaining why. Sondheim said he learned more in those hours than most songwriters learn in a lifetime. He studied music at Williams College, graduated in 1950 and used a prize from the college to take private lessons with the composer Milton Babbitt.

YouTube video

Words first, then everything

His first Broadway credits gave him only half the job. He wrote the lyrics for West Side Story in 1957, to Leonard Bernstein’s music and Arthur Laurents’s book, and then for Gypsy in 1959, after Ethel Merman‘s side insisted on an established composer and Jule Styne got the score. Decades later he called some of his West Side Story lyrics embarrassing, too knowing for a teenage girl from Puerto Rico.

He finally wrote words and music for A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum in 1962, a Roman farce that ran for nearly a thousand performances. Two years later Anyone Can Whistle lasted barely a week. The pattern was already visible: a hit nobody took seriously, then a serious show nobody saw.

The partnership with Prince changed what a musical could be about. Company, in 1970, had no conventional plot, only a bachelor turning thirty-five and the married friends who keep telling him to settle down. Follies followed in 1971, with retired showgirls drinking in a theatre about to be demolished. A Little Night Music (1973) gave him Send in the Clowns, the closest he came to a pop hit; Judy Collins’s recording won him the Grammy for song of the year. Then came Pacific Overtures (1976), Japan’s forced opening to the West staged through kabuki conventions, and Sweeney Todd (1979), a near-operatic thriller in which a wronged barber cuts throats and his landlady bakes the evidence into pies.

After Merrily sank in 1981 he nearly quit the theatre. He found a new partner in the writer and director James Lapine. Sunday in the Park with George (1984), built around Georges Seurat painting his most famous canvas, won the Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1985. Into the Woods (1987) sent fairy-tale characters into a second act where their wishes come with consequences. With John Weidman he wrote Assassins (1990), a revue of the men and women who killed or tried to kill American presidents, and with Lapine again Passion (1994), his most nakedly romantic score.

YouTube video

The case against him

The charge that followed him for most of his career was coldness. Reviewers complained that his characters analysed their feelings instead of singing them, and that his melodies refused to land where the ear expected. Plenty of original productions lost money, and a handful of hits, Sweeney Todd above all, had to carry the reputation. He could be just as severe himself. In Finishing the Hat (2010) and Look, I Made a Hat (2011), two volumes of annotated lyrics, he took apart revered lyricists, Lorenz Hart among them, and was no gentler with his own early work. The tidy image of a solitary genius also flatters the record less than it seems. His best shows were built with book writers who shaped them as much as he did, from George Furth and Hugh Wheeler to Lapine and Weidman. Daniel Okrent’s biography Stephen Sondheim: Art Isn’t Easy, published this year by Yale University Press, draws on a 1982 oral-history interview that only became public after his death, although some reviewers found it thin on the music itself.

The long afterlife

Recognition arrived in bulk anyway. He won eight Tony Awards, a record for a composer, including a special award for lifetime achievement in 2008, along with eight Grammys, the Kennedy Center Honors in 1993 and the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 2015. An Oscar came in 1991 for Sooner or Later, sung by Madonna in Warren Beatty’s Dick Tracy. Broadway renamed Henry Miller’s Theatre after him in 2010, and London’s Queen’s Theatre became the Sondheim Theatre in 2019. In 2017 he married Jeffrey Romley.

Sondheim died at his home in Roxbury, Connecticut, on November 26, 2021, at the age of 91, the day after a Thanksgiving dinner with friends. Steven Spielberg‘s film of West Side Story reached cinemas a few weeks later. His last musical, Here We Are, built from two Luis Buñuel films with a book by David Ives, opened at the Shed in New York in 2023 under Joe Mantello and reached the National Theatre in London in 2025. Marianne Elliott’s revival of Company, which turned the bachelor into a woman with his blessing, won the Tony for best revival in 2022.

The revivals keep coming. Rupert Goold opens a new Assassins at the Old Vic in June 2027, his first musical as the theatre’s artistic director, and the Yard Theatre in east London stages Company that May before a tour of the United Kingdom. Linklater expects to finish his Merrily We Roll Along around 2040. The film tells the story backwards, as the stage show does, with actors who age on camera. If he gets there, the show that lasted sixteen performances in 1981 will have taken nearly six decades to reach the form its author always had in mind.

Selected Recordings

  • A Broadway Extravaganza! (1987)
  • The Stephen Sondheim Album (2000)
  • Sondheim Sings, Vol. I: 1962-72 (2005)
  • Sondheim Sings, Vol. II: 1946-60 (2005)
  • The American Trumpet (2012)

Tags: , , Stephen Sondheim, , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.