Robert Eggers: the filmmaker who has never directed the present

Robert Eggers

Photo: Anna Hanks from Austin, Texas, USA / CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Born	July 7, 1983 New York City, USA
Occupation	Film Director
Known for	The Lighthouse, The Witch, The Northman
Awards	Sundance Film Festival Directing Award: U.S. Dramatic · Bram Stoker · Independent Spirit

Every studio bet against Robert Eggers eventually loses. The director insists on pre-twentieth-century settings, refuses to film modern technology, and has been known to demand dialogue in dead languages — his forthcoming Werwulf is set in fourteenth-century England and spoken entirely in Middle English. His last film, Nosferatu, grossed more than one hundred and eighty million dollars worldwide. The studios have stopped betting against him.

He grew up in Lee, New Hampshire, after a childhood spent partly in Laramie, Wyoming, in a household where an English literature professor stepfather meant that books were a given and the woods at the edge of New England were always close. At seventeen, he directed a stage adaptation of the Nosferatu story at his high school — a fact that would define the shape of his career, since the same project would consume much of the next two decades of his professional life. He trained at the American Musical and Dramatic Academy in New York and spent his early career as a theater designer and director, building the production instinct that now makes his films feel like total environments: every object, every piece of dialogue, every frame is accounted for.

His first feature, The VVitch: A New-England Folktale, arrived in 2015 with its seventeenth-century Puritan dialogue intact and its atmosphere of genuine theological dread. It won the Sundance Film Festival’s Directing Award and the Independent Spirit Award for Best First Screenplay, and it made forty million dollars on a four-million-dollar budget. Critics who expected conventional horror found something closer to a witch-trial transcript brought to terrifying life: a family unraveling on the New England frontier, where the woods hold something that may be real and may be internal, and Eggers refuses to resolve which.

The Lighthouse, released in 2019, pushed further still. Shot in black-and-white on a near-square Academy ratio, it placed Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe on a rocky island and watched them descend into madness in a way that owed more to Melville and Greek myth than to anything Hollywood produced in the intervening century. Dafoe, who has now appeared in four consecutive Eggers films, brings to each a quality of controlled extremity that responds directly to Eggers’ appetite for historical texture as performance context — the world is so specifically built that the character has nowhere to retreat from it.

The harder test came with The Northman in 2022. At a budget of seventy million dollars — more than six times his previous film — it was Eggers’ first production at genuine studio scale, a Viking revenge epic co-written with the Icelandic poet Sjón, with Alexander Skarsgård in the lead and a supporting cast that included Nicole Kidman, Anya Taylor-Joy, and Dafoe. The film opened to strong reviews and crossed seventy-five million dollars globally, but fell short of the break-even threshold at the North American theatrical box office. It was the kind of near-miss that ends careers.

What the near-miss revealed, however, is that Eggers is not a mainstream filmmaker who happens to prefer historical settings. He is a filmmaker of the art-film tradition whose specific subject — folklore, mythology, the primal fears of people who had no secular explanations for what frightened them — occasionally achieves wide commercial reach. The richest passages of The Northman are its ritual sequences, the moments where the Viking world’s internal logic feels genuinely alien and total. The revenge-narrative scaffolding that surrounds them is where the film’s grip loosens, and the scaffolding is what the studio budget obliged him to build. The tension between his instinct and the wider market’s expectations has never fully resolved — which is, in its own way, what makes the career worth watching.

Nosferatu, the project he had been working toward since that high school production, opened Christmas Day 2024 and changed the financial argument permanently. A nineteenth-century Gothic horror drawn from both F.W. Murnau’s 1922 film and Bram Stoker’s novel, it starred Lily-Rose Depp, Bill Skarsgård, and Nicholas Hoult, with Dafoe once again in a supporting role. The film grossed over one hundred and eighty million dollars worldwide — his largest commercial success by a factor of four — and confirmed that period horror executed without irony or self-consciousness could find an audience at the scale that studios require.

The next project, Werwulf, filmed through autumn 2025 and into January 2026 at Sky Studios Elstree outside London and across locations in England and Wales, including Dartmoor and the Forest of Dean. Eggers has described the script, co-written again with Sjón, as the darkest he has written. The film is set in fourteenth-century England and spoken entirely in Middle English — two professors from the University of Oxford were brought in as consultants to ensure linguistic accuracy — and stars Aaron Taylor-Johnson as a man whose community is haunted by a ravenous beast, with Dafoe as a hunter. It is scheduled for Christmas Day 2026, distributed by Focus Features in the United States.

He lives in London with his wife and their son, having relocated from Brooklyn in 2023. The move placed him at the center of the British studio infrastructure he has used for his last two films. Beyond Werwulf, he has spoken about a A Christmas Carol adaptation, a medieval film called The Knight, and a Rasputin project for which filming outside Russia remains an unresolved logistical obstacle. Whether any of those advance will depend, in part, on what the Christmas 2026 audience makes of a horror film where every line of dialogue is spoken in a language that has been dead for six centuries — which is precisely the kind of calculation that has never stopped him before.

Featured Films

Tags: American cinema, Willem Dafoe, Robert Eggers, Nosferatu, The Lighthouse, The VVitch

Featured News — Robert Eggers

See all →

Related People

Birgitte Hjort Sørensen

Charlie Brooker

Featured Films

Featured News — Robert Eggers

The 15 Best A24 Films Ever Made, Ranked by What They Risked

“Nosferatu”: A Gothic Revival in Modern Cinema

The Northman: Robert Eggers’ Viking Take on the Legend Behind Hamlet

Related People

Discussion