Butch Vig, the Nevermind producer back with the Smashing Pumpkins after 33 years

Butch Vig

Photo: Valdo Howell / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Born	August 2, 1955 Viroqua
Occupation	Record Producer
Awards	Grammy Award for Best Rock Album, as producer

The complaint has followed Butch Vig for most of his working life, and it came first from the man whose voice he recorded. Kurt Cobain said he was embarrassed by Nevermind, that it sounded closer to a Mötley Crüe record than to punk rock. The producer supposedly guilty of sanding grunge down for radio then co-founded a band to escape guitar, bass and drums altogether. And the guitar bands keep calling him back. This autumn it is the Smashing Pumpkins, who had not made a record with him since Siamese Dream.

Bryan David Vig grew up in Viroqua, a small town in western Wisconsin, where he was born in August 1955 to DeVerne Vig, a hospital doctor, and Betty Vig, a music teacher. The nickname came from the severe crew cut his father gave him. He studied piano for six years, then traded it for a $60 drum kit after watching the Who on The Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour. At the University of Wisconsin in Madison he enrolled to study film, wrote electronic pieces for low-budget movies, one of which ended up in the B-movie Slumber Party Massacre, and found that shaping sound interested him as much as playing it.

Madison became his workshop. From 1978 he drummed in Spooner alongside Duke Erikson, helped start a small label, Boat Records, to release local bands, and with Steve Marker built a basement studio that grew into Smart Studios. For years he drove a taxi by day and played at night. His next band, Fire Town, signed to Atlantic, and the label put a hired producer on their second album; the sessions went badly and the record sank, but Vig came away with a working education in production technique. Smart turned into the room where loud, abrasive bands came to be recorded, Killdozer, Tad and L7 among them.

That reputation is why Sub Pop sent Nirvana to Madison in April 1990 to record songs for a second album. When the band signed to DGC and the label offered producers who wanted percentage points, Nirvana held out for Vig. They recorded Nevermind at Sound City in Van Nuys in May and June 1991 on a budget of $65,000. Cobain resisted overdubs until Vig told him John Lennon double-tracked his vocals. “He’d be great for an hour, and then he’d sit in a corner and say nothing for an hour,” Vig recalled. The album has sold more than 30 million copies, was certified diamond in the United States and in 2004 entered the Library of Congress National Recording Registry.

The same year he produced Gish, the Smashing Pumpkins’ debut, at Smart. Its sequel was a siege. Siamese Dream was made at Triclops Studios in Marietta, Georgia, where the band had moved to keep their drummer away from his heroin contacts. Vig co-produced with Billy Corgan through 12-hour days that became 15-hour ones, while Corgan often overdubbed his bandmates’ parts with his own playing. “D’arcy would lock herself in the bathroom, James wouldn’t say anything, or Billy would lock himself in the control room,” Vig remembered. Some songs carried up to 100 guitar parts. The sessions took four months and ran $250,000 over budget; the album went seven times platinum. In the same stretch Vig produced Sonic Youth’s Dirty and Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star, and L7’s Bricks Are Heavy.

The slickness charge deserves a closer reading than it usually gets. The polish on Nevermind owes as much to the mix as to the sessions: Vig and the band were unhappy with his own mixes and brought in Andy Wallace, whose work on drums and guitars produced the radio-ready sheen Cobain later disowned. Steve Albini, who engineered In Utero, said Vig’s original mix “sounded maybe 200 times more ass-kicking” than the released album. That rejected mix finally came out on the 20th-anniversary box set. Vig has never pretended the band hated the record when they finished it. Cobain, he said, could not go around saying he loved an album that sold 10 million copies. “That’s just not cool to do.” The verdict that Vig made grunge palatable flatters the producer and blurs the record.

By then he wanted out of the format that had made his name. “By the time I’d done Nevermind, I’d recorded, I swear to God, 1,000 bands that were just guitar-bass-drums,” he said. Excited by records such as Public Enemy’s, built with samplers, he formed Garbage with Marker and Erikson, played drums and recruited the Scottish singer Shirley Manson. Garbage sold more than four million copies; Version 2.0 topped the British chart and was nominated for the Grammy for Album of the Year; the band recorded the Bond theme “The World Is Not Enough”. The tour for Beautiful Garbage was the low point: he caught hepatitis A, then developed Bell’s palsy, and other drummers had to cover his shows. After Bleed Like Me the band went on hiatus, having sold some 17 million albums.

Production filled the gap. Vig produced Green Day’s 21st Century Breakdown, which won the Grammy for Best Rock Album, and reunited with Dave Grohl, now leading Foo Fighters, for Wasting Light. Grohl wanted it cut on analogue tape in the garage of his house in Encino. Vig first thought the idea was a joke, then had to relearn tape editing. The album debuted at number one in the United States, won Best Rock Album, and brought Vig a nomination for Producer of the Year. Since then his steadiest partners have been Silversun Pickups, for whom he produced Widow’s Weeds, Physical Thrills and, in February, Tenterhooks.

Garbage regrouped in 2010. Their eighth album, Let All That We Imagine Be the Light, appeared in 2025, produced by the band with their longtime engineer Billy Bush and partly recorded at Vig’s own studio, Grunge Is Dead. The 2026 tour took them to Edinburgh Castle, in Manson’s home city, and ends with a free concert in Mexico City’s Zócalo on November 14, which Manson has described as the close of three decades of constant bus touring.

The Pumpkins reunion began with a livestream in May, when Corgan said the band had recorded one song with Vig and that it was “98 per cent done”. It turned out to be “Black Stars”, which grew out of Corgan’s sessions for a solo album; Vig helped him choose the song that best fit the story. They tracked it at Chaplin Studios in Los Angeles, with additional sessions in Chicago. The song appears on The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping (The Album), released by MCA on November 13, a week before the film opens.

Vig is married to Beth Halper, a former DreamWorks A&R executive; they have a daughter, Bo Violet, and live in the Silver Lake neighbourhood of Los Angeles.

November gives him two endings in one week: the soundtrack carrying his first Pumpkins production in more than three decades, and the last night of Garbage’s long bus-touring era in the largest square in Mexico. Neither sounds like a retirement. The man accused of making rock too clean is still the one rock bands trust to tell them what they actually sound like.

Tags: singers, The Smashing Pumpkins, record producers, Butch Vig, Siamese Dream, Garbage

Related People

Related People

Discussion