Tinashe’s ‘Pillow Fight’ previewed her first Billboard 200 top 10 album

Tinashe released “Pillow Fight” and “I’d Rather Be Alone” together, two songs that pull in opposite directions: a flirtatious R&B track built around desire and a breakup ballad about walking out of a toxic relationship. The pair was the final preview of Popstar, the album that now holds the best Billboard 200 debut of her career.

That chart result is why the pair deserves a second listen. Tinashe has been releasing albums for more than a decade, and her previous peak on the Billboard 200 was No. 17 with her major-label debut, Aquarius. Popstar entered at No. 6 with 35,500 equivalent album units, around 22,000 of them pure sales, according to Billboard. In a market run on streams, that sales share points to fans who buy the record, not just a viral clip.

Recommended ReadingLisa’s “Rockstar”:Thai Rapper and Singer’s New Single Tops Charts in Korea

“Pillow Fight”, produced by Ricky Reed, opens on a sample of Laura Branigan’s “Self Control” before settling into a steady, unhurried groove that critics have compared to Mariah Carey’s R&B singles of the nineties. The video, directed by Zac Wiesel, keeps Tinashe on a run of beds in a dark room under falling feathers, with choreography that includes flips and splits and her eyes fixed on the camera.

“I’d Rather Be Alone” runs the other way. Airy synths and electric guitar carry a song about reaching a breaking point with a partner, and it arrived without a video, as a promotional single rather than an official one. HotNewHipHop’s Alexander Cole framed the split simply: “Pillow Fight” has the party energy, while its companion is “all about the ballads”.

The two songs closed a campaign that began with “Too Easy”, “Crash Out” and “Melatonin”. Popstar is also the first real test of what her TikTok years were worth: “Nasty” gave Tinashe her first Hot 100 entry as a solo artist, and the Disco Lines remix of “No Broke Boys” climbed higher still, to No. 36. Viral singles do not automatically turn into album listening, and this record was the proof the label needed.

The double release had a cost. Two songs on the same day compete for the same playlists and the same news cycle, and “I’d Rather Be Alone”, with no video behind it, was always going to be the quieter half. “Pillow Fight” also leans on familiar references, a borrowed eighties hook and a Mariah-style melody, which makes it easy to like before it sounds like anyone in particular. And a No. 6 debut on 35,500 units is a career high, not a commercial takeover by the standard of the albums sitting above it.

Critics have been warmer than the charts. Popstar holds a Metacritic score of 88 from seven reviews, NME gave it five stars, and Pitchfork’s Anna Gaca called it “the best pop album of the year”. Billboard’s Kyle Denis described the 16-track set as moving through hyperpop, R&B, dance, jazz, new age and bedroom pop.

“Pillow Fight” and “I’d Rather Be Alone” came out worldwide on September 10 through Tinashe Music, Nice Life and Atlantic Records, and Popstar followed on September 25. Tinashe will play the album live in three US shows billed as Three Nights With a Popstar, in Chicago, at the Brooklyn Paramount on October 24 and at the Hollywood Palladium in Los Angeles on November 7. No dates outside the United States have been announced.

Tags: pop, I’d Rather Be Alone, Pillow Fight, Popstar, Tinashe

More Like This

Taylor Swift’s ‘The Life of a Showgirl’ Is No. 1 Again on the Billboard 200, and This Time Streaming Did It

Kim Petras to Release Debut Album ‘Feed The Beast’ – Watch the Video for the Single ‘Alone’!

Madonna Confessions II: why the unanimous critical praise demands an explanation

Kesha’s New Album ‘Gag Order’ Out Now! Watch the Video Here!

Miley Cyrus opens her 10th album era with a dance-floor single and ‘80s synths

Peach PRC Releases New Single “Perfect For You” Today