Movies

Michel Franco and Jessica Chastain turn a love affair into a class autopsy in ‘Dreams’

Veronica Loop

A wealthy San Francisco arts patron underwrites the careers of young dancers, and one of those dancers shares her bed. In Michel Franco’s Dreams, that arrangement is never quite a romance. It is a transaction both people keep mistaking for love, and the film’s tension comes from watching how long each of them can sustain the mistake before the money in the room makes itself heard.

Jennifer is the benefactor. Fernando is the gifted Mexican dancer who crosses the border without papers to be near her and, just as urgently, to be seen on a stage that matters. Franco sets desire and dependency pointing in opposite directions, then asks the only question that interests him: when the person with money decides how much of the person without it she is willing to keep, what is left of either of them.

YouTube video

Jessica Chastain plays Jennifer as composure with a hairline crack running through it, a woman whose generosity is real and whose control is more real still. The casting is also a statement of intent: Chastain produced the film through her Freckle Films banner and clearly went looking for a part with no soft edges, a benefactor the audience is not allowed to simply admire. Opposite her, Isaac Hernández, a principal dancer in life rather than a trained screen actor, plays Fernando. The choice is a wager that a real dancer’s body carries more truth than an actor’s imitation of one, and it pays off whenever the film stops talking and lets him move.

Around them, Rupert Friend plays Jennifer’s brother as the family’s reflex for self-protection, the relative who recognizes a liability before anyone names it. Eligio Meléndez and Mercedes Hernández anchor the other end of the social ladder as Fernando’s parents, a counterweight the film needs and does not always use. The ballet world supplies the perfect setting for Franco’s argument: an art form that sells transcendence while running on patronage, where a dancer’s career can depend entirely on which donor decides he is worth the investment.

Franco makes films that refuse to console the viewer. The fixed camera, the withheld reaction shot, the violence that arrives without a single bar of music to prepare you for it: these are his signature, and they are all here. Dreams is his second film with Chastain after Memory, and the partnership has become a reliable delivery system for his coldest instincts. The film premiered in competition at the Berlin Film Festival, where it chased the Golden Bear, before traveling to Sarajevo and Rome.

The real border in Dreams is not only the one Fernando crosses on foot. It runs straight through the relationship. Franco treats class as the mechanism that decides who is permitted to dream and who is merely useful to someone else’s dream, and he is careful never to let Jennifer’s good intentions launder the imbalance underneath them. Migration here is not a cause to be championed. It is a power differential to be examined, coolly, from a distance that some viewers will read as honesty and others as a shrug.

That is the film’s central risk, and it does not fully resolve it. What Dreams never settles is whether its detachment is an argument or an alibi. The reviews have split almost down the middle. One camp praised Chastain’s nerve and the film’s refusal to flatter its affluent liberal characters; the other found it airless, a thesis staged rather than dramatized, its cruelty observed but never quite felt. Casting a non-actor in the second lead sharpens the realism and, in the longer dialogue scenes, occasionally exposes the seams. The film diagnoses class cruelty with clinical precision while declining to take a position on it, and audiences will reasonably disagree about whether that restraint is rigor or evasion.

The commercial reality is its own kind of test. A chamber piece this severe was never built for wide returns, and its US theatrical run was a modest one, the kind of arthouse figure that arthouse distributors expect and budget around. The interesting number is the other one: The Match Factory placed the film across most of Western and Eastern Europe and into Asia, and a streaming home on Starz gives it the long tail that a small box office cannot. This is how a Franco film is meant to earn out, slowly, festival to festival and territory to territory, rather than in a single opening weekend.

Written, directed and produced by Franco, Dreams was made by AR Content, Eastern Film, Freckle Films and Teorema, with Eréndira Núñez Larios and Alexander Rodnyansky among the producers. The supporting cast includes Marshall Bell as Jennifer’s father. It runs 98 minutes.

The film opened in Mexican cinemas last autumn and reached US theaters through Greenwich Entertainment on February 27, with a Starz streaming debut set for June 1. Its international rollout widens this month: a Spanish theatrical release arrives June 19 through Sideral, with further European and Asian dates still to be confirmed. Whatever verdict it earns market by market, Dreams is the rare prestige release engineered to send you home uncomfortable, and Franco has never once cared whether you thank him for it.

Cast

Tags: , , , , ,

Discussion

There are 0 comments.