Authors

Stan Lee, the comic book writer whose byline is still on trial

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Stan Lee
Stan Lee
Photo: US Embassy Tokyo / Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
BornDecember 28, 1922
Manhattan, New York City, United States
DiedNovember 12, 2018 (95)
OccupationComic book writer
Known forAvengers: Infinity War, The Avengers, Avengers: Endgame
AwardsWill Eisner Award Hall of Fame · Jack Kirby Hall of Fame · National Medal of Arts · 2 Alley · Inkpot · Science Fiction and Fantasy Hall of Fame

This year an AI voice company added Stan Lee to its catalogue. Anyone can now license a digital copy of the man who signed off his Marvel columns with “Excelsior!”. It is a fitting and slightly uneasy afterlife for a writer whose authorship has never been fully settled. Lee’s name sits on the stories that introduced Spider-Man, the Fantastic Four, the X-Men, Thor and the Hulk, yet the artists who drew them, above all Jack Kirby and Steve Ditko, spent decades insisting that they had done much of the writing too.

What nobody disputes is the voice. Lee wrote like a carnival barker who had read too much Shakespeare, and his heroes worried about rent, sulked, caught colds and quarrelled with one another. That move, from flawless champions to anxious people in costumes, goes a long way toward explaining why superhero comics found teenage and college readers, and why film studios are still adapting those characters today.

He was born Stanley Martin Lieber on December 28, 1922, in an apartment on Manhattan’s Upper West Side, the elder son of Romanian Jewish immigrants, and grew up wanting to write the Great American Novel. In 1939, at sixteen, he became an assistant at Timely Comics, the comics arm of pulp publisher Martin Goodman, who was married to his cousin. He filled inkwells and erased pencil lines. His first published piece, a text story in Captain America Comics #3 in 1941, carried a pen name meant to keep his real one clean for the novel: Stan Lee. When Joe Simon and Kirby walked out later that year, Goodman made the teenager interim editor. Apart from wartime Army service, he held the editor’s chair until 1972.

By the late fifties, after years of churning out westerns and romances, he was thinking of quitting. When DC’s revived superheroes started to sell, Goodman asked for a team of his own. His wife Joan, whom he had married in 1947, told him to write what he actually liked. The result, drawn by Kirby, was Fantastic Four in 1961: a family of heroes who bickered. Within two years the same small workshop produced the Hulk, Iron Man and the X-Men, and the Mighty Thor arrived in Journey into Mystery, co-created with Kirby and Lee’s brother Larry Lieber. In Amazing Fantasy #15, cover-dated August 1962, Lee and Ditko introduced a teenager from Queens whose first story ended with a line about great power and great responsibility.

To keep a dozen titles moving, Lee worked in what became known as the Marvel Method. He talked a plot through with the artist, who broke it into pages; Lee then added captions and dialogue to the finished pencils. He credited inkers and letterers, used his monthly Stan’s Soapbox column to attack bigotry, and wrote the letters pages so chummily that fans addressed them to “Stan and Jack” rather than “Dear Editor”. With Kirby he built The Galactus Trilogy in 1966, which introduced Galactus and the Silver Surfer, and their Fantastic Four run also gave mainstream comics its first Black superhero, Black Panther. In 1971 Lee published a three-issue The Amazing Spider-Man story about drug addiction without the Comics Code seal; the Code was loosened soon afterwards.

The same method explains the long fight over credit. Both Kirby and Ditko came to feel that a byline reading “Stan Lee” first misdescribed who had done what. Reference accounts now describe The Galactus Trilogy as written, co-plotted and drawn by Kirby, with Lee as editor. Ditko left Marvel in 1966; Kirby later caricatured Lee as the huckster Funky Flashman in DC’s Mister Miracle. Josephine Riesman’s 2021 biography, True Believer, went further, arguing that Lee embellished much of his own legend. His tale of winning a newspaper essay contest three weeks running is better documented as a seventh-place prize. None of that erases what Lee demonstrably wrote: the dialogue, the captions, the voice. It does mean that a sentence beginning “Stan Lee created” should almost always continue with “and”.

In 1972 Lee gave up monthly writing to become publisher, and his name came to mean a public role more than a byline. He still wrote. Origins of Marvel Comics followed in 1974, and in 1978 two of his most durable titles appeared: The Silver Surfer: The Ultimate Cosmic Experience with Kirby, often called Marvel’s first graphic novel, and How to Draw Comics the Marvel Way with John Buscema, the manual that trained a generation of cartoonists. In 1985 he wrote the X-Men into Heroes for Hope, a famine-relief comic that also featured Stephen King. After stepping back from daily duties he reimagined Superman and Batman for DC in Just Imagine…, conceived the manga and anime Heroman with the Japanese studio Bones, and in Stan Lee Meets… let his creations tell him how irritating he was.

Honours included the Will Eisner Award Hall of Fame in 1994 and the National Medal of Arts in 2008. On screen, his cameos in Marvel adaptations, an old man in tinted glasses winking at the audience, made him the actor with the highest-grossing film total ever. He died at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles on November 12, 2018, aged 95, a year after Joan, his wife of 69 years. Those last years were darker than the cameos suggested, clouded by lawsuits and reports of elder abuse. This July, Stan Lee: The Final Chapter, a documentary by his former assistant Jon Bolerjack, returned to how the cash from his signings and appearances was handled; the former manager at the centre of the film denies taking Lee’s money.

YouTube video

The voice licence is the latest turn in that story. Lee spent his life turning a personality into a brand, and that personality is now the asset that outlived him, available on demand. Open an early Fantastic Four or The Amazing Spider-Man and what still feels alive is the argument Lee started with his artists: that a hero could be broke, frightened and still in high school, and worth following every month.

Tags: , , , , , Stan Lee

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.