Movies

A Clockwork Orange: Kubrick’s gorgeous, dangerous question about free will

Molly Se-kyung

It begins with a stare. Malcolm McDowell, eyes ringed in liner, chin down and brow up, looks straight into the lens while Wendy Carlos’s synthesised Beethoven hums underneath — and around him the Korova Milkbar glows white, its furniture moulded into fibreglass mannequins, its language a teenage argot nobody had ever heard. In a single shot, A Clockwork Orange tells you that you are somewhere new and not entirely safe.

What follows is the most uncomfortable question Kubrick ever put on screen. Alex DeLarge loves Beethoven and ‘ultra-violence’ in roughly equal measure; he leads his droogs through a night of assault and worse, is betrayed and jailed, then volunteers for the Ludovico Technique — an aversion treatment that leaves him physically sick at the very thought of harming anyone. Released ‘cured’, he is defenceless, a political pawn, a man who can no longer choose. Adapting Anthony Burgess, Kubrick poses the riddle and refuses to answer it: is a man who cannot choose evil still a man at all?

YouTube video

A design nobody had seen before

Half a century later the film’s surfaces are still being copied. John Alcott’s wide-angle lenses warp the near-future Britain into something cold and clinical; the production design — the Korova, the codpieces and bowler hats, the brutalist flats — turned dystopia into pop art. And then there is the sound. Wendy (then Walter) Carlos reworked Beethoven, Rossini and Purcell on the Moog synthesiser, so that the Ninth Symphony becomes Alex’s private ecstasy and Rossini scores his beatings. Most famous of all, Alex capers through a home invasion to Gene Kelly’s ‘Singin’ in the Rain’ — a moment McDowell improvised on set, weaponising joy. Kubrick makes beauty and brutality share the frame and never lets you off the hook about it.

Malcolm McDowell’s Alex

The film belongs to McDowell, and it would not exist without him. His Alex is charming, witty, articulate and monstrous — a narrator who confides in you, makes you laugh, then does something unforgivable while you are still smiling. It is one of the great destabilising performances in English-language cinema, precisely because it never lets the audience feel safely superior. The supporting cast plays broad and theatrical by design — Patrick Magee’s writer all bulging eyes and grief, Aubrey Morris’s oily Deltoid — a deliberate caricature that reads, for some viewers, as the film’s coldness made flesh.

Malcolm McDowell as Alex in A Clockwork Orange (1971)
A Clockwork Orange (1971), directed by Stanley Kubrick.

The film that vanished from Britain

No Kubrick film carries a stranger afterlife. Rated X in the United States, the picture became a lightning rod in Britain after newspapers tied a handful of crimes to its imagery. Facing reported threats to his family, Kubrick himself asked Warner Bros. to withdraw it from UK distribution — and it stayed effectively unavailable there until after his death in 1999. A whole British generation grew up unable to legally see the most talked-about film of its era. The critics split too: Roger Ebert dismissed it as ‘an ideological mess, a paranoid right-wing fantasy’; Pauline Kael recoiled from its sympathy for Alex; while Empire and many others defended it as one of Kubrick’s finest. Four Oscar nominations, no wins.

Why it still earns its place

The originality is total and the craft is overwhelming — there is no other film shaped quite like this one, and almost nothing in it has dated. What keeps A Clockwork Orange off the very summit is the same thing that makes it unforgettable: it is a cold provocation by design. The second half is deliberately schematic, the satire keeps you at arm’s length, and the objection raised by Ebert and Kael — that the film is more in love with Alex’s vitality than with his victims’ pain — is a real, defensible reservation rather than a flaw to wave away. Naming that chill is what keeps the admiration honest. More than fifty years on, it remains one of the most beautiful, most quoted and most genuinely dangerous films ever made.

A Clockwork Orange was released in 1971, written, directed and produced by Stanley Kubrick from the 1962 novel by Anthony Burgess. It was photographed by John Alcott, scored by Wendy Carlos, and stars Malcolm McDowell, Patrick Magee, Adrienne Corri and Warren Clarke. It received four Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture and Best Director.

Tags: , , ,

Discussion

There are 0 comments.