The moment Kelp first sets eyes on his reflection in the shimmering ocean waves is the heart of Kalee StClair’s Not Quite Narwhal. The little narwhal—er, unicorn—gasps at his spiraled horn, a visual punch that instantly communicates the show’s central premise. Based on Jessie Sima’s beloved picture book, this animated series for kids is as vibrant and whimsical as its aquatic setting suggests, but it’s also surprisingly grounded in themes of identity and belonging.

StClair’s adaptation stays faithful to the source material, following Kelp (voiced with wide-eyed wonder by Nevin Kar) as he navigates two vastly different worlds: the deep sea where he was raised among narwhals and the glittering unicorn meadows above. The animation is a feast for young eyes, with bold colors and playful character designs that make even the simplest scenes feel alive. The underwater sequences, in particular, are a standout—shimmering blues and purples create a dreamy, immersive atmosphere that perfectly captures the magic of Kelp’s narwhal home.

Where Not Quite Narwhal truly shines is in its message. Unlike many kids’ shows that rely on conflict or villainy to drive the plot, this series keeps things simple and sweet. Kelp’s journey isn’t about overcoming adversaries but about embracing who he really is, with the support of his friends—both old and new. The voice cast delivers performances that feel warm and authentic, particularly Lucy Lowe as Scallop, whose gentle encouragement helps Kelp see the best in himself.

That said, the show isn’t without its flaws. While the storytelling is straightforward and accessible for young audiences, it occasionally feels a bit too simplistic even for its target demographic. Some episodes stretch thin, relying on repetition rather than fresh insights to drive their points home. The unicorn world, while visually striking, sometimes lacks the depth of the underwater sequences, making Kelp’s transition feel less earned than it could be.

Still, Not Quite Narwhal succeeds where it matters most: in its ability to make kids feel seen and valued. It’s a show that celebrates difference without resorting to heavy-handed moralizing, and that’s no small feat.