El Clásico, Barcelona v Real Madrid: the matchups that decide it, ranked — and Mbappé against the high line is only second

Barcelona have won every league game they have played this season, and Real Madrid arrive at Camp Nou having scored four goals in each of their last three matches. On paper the Clásico looks like a contest between two attacks. Look at how both teams are built and it is narrower than that: a fight over the few seconds after Barcelona lose the ball.

Hansi Flick‘s side defend by shrinking the pitch, with a back line pushed up towards halfway and a press that tries to win the ball back before the opponent can turn. José Mourinho‘s Madrid, without the suspended Vinícius Júnior, have played their best football of the season this month by passing through pressure rather than going around it. Every matchup below either feeds that contest or depends on it.

So the five duels are ranked by how much of the rest of the match each one decides: how often it will be tested, and how directly winning it produces a chance. On that measure the duel everyone will watch, Kylian Mbappé against Barcelona’s high line, comes second. First is the one that decides how often he gets to run at all.

Recommended ReadingWales Without Rodon as Bellamy Hands Cian Ashford His First Call-Up

The table sets the stakes. Barcelona have won all nine league games, scoring 39 and conceding nine, and a tenth win would make them the first side in Spanish history to open a league season with ten straight victories. Madrid are third, six points behind, after defeats at Real Betis and in the Madrid derby. Barcelona lost 4-2 in Paris on Tuesday and Madrid beat RB Leipzig 4-1 on Wednesday, so Mourinho, in his first Clásico for 13 years, has a day less to recover before Sunday’s 9pm kick-off.

1. Barcelona’s counter-press against Madrid’s first pass: Rodri and Pedri v Arda Güler and Jude Bellingham

A high line is only as safe as the press in front of it. When Barcelona lose the ball, Rodri and Pedri, the double pivot Flick built after Rodri arrived from Manchester City, have to shut down the first pass before the opponent can look forward. Paris showed what happens when that first wave is beaten. Paris Saint-Germain sat in a mid-block, and each time they got past the initial press they needed only a few passes to reach the back four. The late goals from Vitinha and Fabián Ruiz came as Barcelona pushed for a winner with a tiring midfield.

This is where Mourinho’s change in the past week matters. Against Sevilla he moved Federico Valverde to right-back and dropped Güler into the double pivot beside Aurélien Tchouaméni, who anchors while Güler takes the ball under pressure and plays forward. When Sevilla pressed late to chase the game, Güler and Dean Huijsen passed straight through it into the space behind. Bellingham, a line higher, is the second receiver. If either turns behind Rodri and Pedri, Madrid are running at the back four. If Barcelona’s pair stop that turn, the high line never has to defend open grass. No other duel will be tested as often.

2. Kylian Mbappé against the high line: Pau Cubarsí and Gerard Martín

Mbappé has nine league goals and has scored in all three of Madrid’s European games. With Vinícius out he is the whole of Madrid’s threat in behind. The line he will run at has been thinned by the past week: Eric García is out for three to four weeks with a thigh injury, Andreas Christensen is unavailable and Jules Koundé is a doubt with an ankle sprain. That probably leaves Pau Cubarsí, whose strength is reading the play and passing forward, beside Gerard Martín, who has only just returned from an ankle problem.

Flick will not drop the line, because it is what lets Barcelona win the ball high. The question is how often Mbappé gets the space behind it, and that is decided in the first duel. This one ranks second because it is the consequence rather than the cause: every time Madrid win the first pass, it is played at full speed, with two centre-backs running towards their own goal and Joan García, whose saves kept the score close in Paris, as the last line.

3. Lamine Yamal against Marc Cucurella, and who comes to help

Barcelona’s clearest individual advantage is on the right. Lamine Yamal has eight league goals and six assists; he starts wide and wants to come inside onto his left foot. Marc Cucurella, who came through Barcelona’s academy, faces the same choice every time. If he follows Yamal inside, the space outside him opens for Xavi Espart overlapping from right-back. If he holds his position, Yamal receives the ball facing goal.

The answer is a second defender, and that is where Madrid’s attacking choices start to cost them. Yan Diomande, likely on Madrid’s left, would have to track Espart back, which takes width away from Madrid’s own attack. The duel ranks third because Barcelona will win parts of it whatever happens. What Mourinho can choose is how much of his attack he spends containing it.

4. Fermín López between the lines against Aurélien Tchouaméni

Dani Olmo’s adductor injury in Paris, expected to keep him out for about a month, changes Barcelona’s number ten. Fermín López is the likely replacement, and he is less a combiner who drops towards the ball than a runner who arrives late. After coming on in Paris he played the third-man pass that sent Espart through for the first equaliser.

His target is the space Güler leaves when Madrid lose the ball. Tchouaméni can hold the centre, but if Güler is a step late getting back, as he was a few times against Sevilla, Fermín has room between Madrid’s midfield and defence. It ranks fourth because it depends on the first duel going the other way: Fermín only gets that space after Madrid have committed players forward and lost the ball.

5. Madrid’s width without Vinícius: Diomande and Endrick against Barcelona’s full-backs

The last duel is Madrid’s own shape. Vinícius is suspended after his red card against Villarreal and Rodrygo is injured. Against Sevilla, Mourinho used Diomande on the left and Endrick on the right, with Valverde behind Endrick because, he said, he wanted a full-back there who could drop deep and still play. Diomande replaced Vinícius against his old club Leipzig and needed about 20 minutes to set up one goal and score another.

Their job is to pin Espart and João Cancelo back so that Barcelona’s full-backs cannot join the press. If they stay high, Madrid’s first pass gets easier. If Yamal and Anthony Gordon drag them back, Madrid break with Mbappé alone. It ranks last because it is a question of Mourinho’s choices more than a contest between players: the risk he takes on the wings decides how many men he has left to defend.

The pattern beneath the list

Put the five together and the match comes down to one cycle. Barcelona lose the ball. Either they win it back within seconds, or Madrid’s first pass gets out and Mbappé runs at a back line missing two of its usual centre-backs. In Paris that cycle turned against Flick late on, when his midfield tired and his line stayed high. Madrid have a day less rest, but with Güler deeper they have found a way to play through pressure that they did not have a month ago.

Barcelona have built a record-equalling start on winning those seconds. To make the record their own, they have to win them again with a tired midfield and a makeshift centre-back pairing.

Tags: Kylian Mbappé, Lamine Yamal, Real Madrid, FC Barcelona, Hansi Flick, José Mourinho

More Like This

Netherlands – Japan: 2-2, and the triple change that handed Japan a way back

Harry Kane Slipped on the Penalty That Could Have Sunk Spain — and England’s Captain Still Wants the Next One

Alexander Isak’s Return to St James’ Park: a Year at Liverpool Has Made the Most Expensive Man in England the Loneliest

Croatia don’t win in ninety minutes — they outlast you, and at 40 Modrić still sets the clock

Lionel Messi, after beating England: “The fans wanted this victory more than any other”

The United States Beat Australia Without Pulisic — and Pochettino’s Fix Showed How Much They Still Need Him