Science

Montana’s blue suckers live past 130, and few young fish replace them

Peter Finch
Add us on Google

A fish swimming in Montana’s Missouri River today may have hatched when Montana had been a state for only a few years. Blue suckers, a slender blue-grey river fish often labelled a worthless “rough fish”, live for well over a century, according to a study that counted the growth rings in their ear stones and then checked those counts against the radioactive carbon left behind by nuclear bomb tests.

The oldest fish in the sample was one hundred and thirty-one years old, and half of the forty-two fish examined were ninety-nine or older. That makes the blue sucker one of the longest-lived animals in North America. It also exposes a quiet emergency: the population is made almost entirely of very old adults, and very few young fish have joined it since large dams reshaped the river.

The work was co-led by fisheries scientist Alec Lackmann of the University of Minnesota Duluth, with Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks biologist Luke Holmquist and fisheries biologist Allen Andrews of the University of Hawaii at Manoa. Earlier studies of the species had found maximum ages of 42 and 61 years. The new figure more than doubles the higher of those two numbers.

“When age estimates are that much older than previously thought, an additional line of evidence is needed to rigorously test their validity,” Lackmann said in a statement from the university.

How nuclear bomb carbon confirmed the ages

Almost every bony fish carries otoliths, small stones of calcium carbonate inside the skull that help with hearing and balance. They add a layer every year, much like the rings of a tree. Blue suckers have three pairs, and they are tiny and fragile, which is one reason earlier studies relied on fin rays and scales, structures that tend to underestimate the age of old fish.

The team cut one type of ear stone into slices a few tenths of a millimetre thick and had three readers count the yearly bands under a microscope. The readers agreed closely: their counts varied by a median of about 9 percent. “Blue suckers have extremely small otoliths, smaller than the buffalofishes, but we figured out how to work with them,” Lackmann said.

Counting bands is not proof on its own, so the researchers turned to a second clock. Atmospheric tests of thermonuclear weapons in the late 1950s and early 1960s more than doubled the amount of radiocarbon in the air. That spike passed into rivers and into any animal growing at the time, leaving a dated marker in its tissues. If a fish’s band count is right, the jump in radiocarbon should appear exactly in the bands laid down around the late 1950s.

The team drilled tiny samples, about 0.2 milligrams each, from a second type of ear stone and measured them with an accelerator mass spectrometer at ETH Zurich in Switzerland. The radiocarbon rise sat where the band counts predicted, both across different fish and along the growth layers of single fish. In one 119-year-old fish, a series of samples from the core outward traced the whole bomb signal, from low pre-test values through the peak and the slow decline afterward.

A river fish that outlives most people

The result places the blue sucker in a small club. Among freshwater fish, only the bigmouth buffalo comes close, at 148 years in the paper’s comparison table, while an older, unvalidated estimate of 152 years exists for the lake sturgeon. The blue sucker is the fourth member of the sucker family found to pass 100 years, after the bigmouth, smallmouth and black buffalo, all identified in the past few years.

The long life surprised the authors because blue suckers live year-round in fast currents, an energy-hungry habitat that biologists expect to favour shorter lives. The Montana fish sit at the northern edge of the species’ range, and in fishes, maximum lifespan generally rises with latitude, which may explain part of the gap with populations farther south.

Growth almost stops in adulthood. Females, the larger sex, reach 95 percent of their final length of about 83 centimetres by around 36 years, males by about 14 years. Seven tagged fish recaptured after up to 10 years had grown about a millimetre a year. A fish that looks middle-sized can therefore be decades or a century old, and length alone says almost nothing about age.

Old fish, very few young ones

Montana biologists have measured 1,056 blue suckers in this stretch of the Missouri since the mid-1990s. More than 95 percent were longer than 65 centimetres, and juveniles have stayed rare despite repeated searches. The ages explain why. Hatch years in the sample stretched back to 1892, the most common ones fell in the mid-1920s, and about 64 percent hatched before Fort Peck Dam was completed in 1940. Canyon Ferry Dam followed in 1954 and Tiber Dam on the Marias River in 1956.

Statistical models found that young fish were more likely to survive in years with high spring floods, and that peak spring flows at Fort Benton have fallen over 135 years of records. Even at the same flow, successful years became less likely after the dams. The fish are not too old to breed: all the females examined, aged 19 to 130, carried mature eggs, producing roughly 82,000 to 239,000 each. Most males showed testicular abnormalities such as tumours, but they still produced sperm.

The pattern echoes the pallid sturgeon, a federally endangered fish in the same river that has produced almost no wild young since the dams. The blue sucker is listed as threatened or a similar category in 22 of the 23 US states where it is native, and as a Species of Concern in Montana, where there are no rules on harvest or waste. One fish in the study, estimated at 100 years old, was found discarded whole by an angler.

What the study doesn’t settle

The sample is modest: 42 fish from a single population, collected mostly from spring spawning gatherings. The authors argue it matches decades of size data from the river, but other populations, such as those in Texas or Illinois, may age differently. Whether blue suckers elsewhere reach similar ages is still unknown.

The link to the dams is a correlation, and a weak one in statistical terms. The models explain only 10 to 16 percent of the variation in which years produced surviving young, and they do not account for natural deaths over more than a century, which thin out the oldest year classes. Small errors in band counting also blur the year-class picture, a known problem in very old fish.

The mechanism is open as well. Dams change flow, water temperature, turbidity, the connection to side channels where young fish shelter, and the mix of predators. The study cannot say which of these matters most, and the authors call research on the survival of young blue suckers urgent. The black and orange spots that become more common with age could one day allow ageing without killing fish, but that method is not yet calibrated.

Common questions about the blue sucker

How long do blue suckers live?

In Montana’s Upper Missouri River, blue suckers can live at least 131 years, according to ear-stone ages validated with bomb radiocarbon. Half of the 42 fish studied were 99 or older. Earlier studies elsewhere had found maximum ages of 42 and 61 years.

What is a blue sucker?

The blue sucker, Cycleptus elongatus, is a migratory freshwater fish of the sucker family native to the Mississippi River basin and rivers draining to the Gulf of Mexico. It has a long, slender blue-grey body and a small mouth on the underside of its head for feeding on the river bottom.

How do scientists know how old a fish is?

They count yearly growth bands in the otoliths, tiny ear stones inside the skull. For very old fish, they confirm the count with bomb radiocarbon dating, which looks for the carbon spike from nuclear tests of the late 1950s and early 1960s in the bands that should match those years.

Is the blue sucker endangered?

It is not on the US federal endangered list, but 22 of the 23 states where it is native list it as threatened, imperiled or a similar category. In Montana it is a Species of Concern, and this study suggests few young fish are replacing the old adults.

Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks surveys the river’s blue suckers each spring, when the fish gather to spawn. The authors call for an urgent reassessment of the species’ status and for studies of how young fish survive below the dams. The youngest fish in this sample hatched in 2015.

Reference: Lackmann et al., “Bomb-radiocarbon validated otoliths reveal 130-year lifespans and declining recruitment for blue sucker Cycleptus elongatus of the Upper Missouri River, Montana, USA,” Communications Biology, 2026. DOI: 10.1038/s42003-026-11219-3

Tags: , , , , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.