Todd Stashwick, VisionQuest’s Paladin and the actor who dares you to like him

Todd Stashwick

Photo: Kevin Paul / CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Born	October 16, 1968 Chicago, Illinois, United States
Occupation	Actor and writer
Known for	The Accountant², The Rundown, Along Came Polly

Captain Liam Shaw does not want the old crew on his ship. When Jean-Luc Picard and William Riker talk their way aboard the USS Titan, Shaw refuses their request, gets overruled by his own first officer and prepares to hand a young fugitive over to the bounty hunter chasing them. In the third season of Star Trek: Picard he exists to slow the reunion down. Todd Stashwick played him so that the obstacle became the reason a good part of the audience kept watching. He once described the trick as “bringing an audience in and daring them to like you while giving them all the reasons not to.” It sums up his career, and Marvel is about to test it at a scale he has never worked on.

The ambition came early. Raised in the suburbs just outside Chicago, Stashwick wanted, as a boy, to make people laugh on a Second City stage. He took a theatre degree at Illinois State University, worked the city’s smaller improv rooms, and then The Second City hired him for its national touring company.

Stashwick, born in October 1968 at Chicago’s Swedish Covenant Hospital, joined that tour in 1992. After stints at Second City Detroit and Second City Northwest he moved to New York and auditioned for Saturday Night Live. Los Angeles then turned the improviser into a working screen actor, and for two decades the work followed a pattern. He recurred on American Dreams and Still Standing, then settled into the part casting offices kept sending him: the guest heavy who arrives for an episode or two and gives the hero someone to beat. Burn Notice, Justified and Hawaii Five-0 all used him that way. He wore Romulan make-up for one episode of Star Trek: Enterprise. On Heroes he played Eli, and when the artist Dennis Calero drew that character for an online comic tied to the series, the two men met and started working together.

The first role that let him hold the screen for a full season was Dale Malloy in The Riches, the FX drama in which Eddie Izzard and Minnie Driver play Irish Travellers who steal the house and identities of a dead wealthy couple. Dale is Dahlia’s cousin, raised alongside Wayne like a brother and certain that he would one day marry her and lead the clan. Wayne gets in the way of all of it, and the grudge curdles into something close to sociopathy. Stashwick played the menace as injured pride, which made Dale the most legible person in a family of liars.

The meeting that changed the shape of his career happened on Syfy. Terry Matalas and Travis Fickett’s 12 Monkeys, a time-travel series loosely built on Terry Gilliam’s film, cast him as Theodore Deacon, leader of the West VII, a brutal band of survivors in a plague-wrecked 2043. Deacon arrived as a recurring threat. From the second season Stashwick was a series regular, and the writers kept folding the scavenger deeper into the story. Once the show ended, Disney handed him a lighter assignment, the mad scientist Dr. Drakken in its live-action Kim Possible.

When Matalas took charge of the final season of Star Trek: Picard, he pitched the Titan’s commander to his writers in a single line: “Just imagine Captain Stashwick.” Nobody else was considered. Shaw is a pragmatist who, in Stashwick’s words, “suffers no fools,” and his hostility toward Picard has a source: in a holodeck scene he recounts serving as a young engineer at the Battle of Wolf 359, the massacre carried out by a Borg-assimilated Picard. When Shaw died in the ninth episode, “Võx”, handing command of the Titan to Seven of Nine, the protest was loud enough that the actor answered it directly: “if fans are upset by his death, what can I say? This isn’t Law and Order.” The performance brought him a Saturn Award nomination for best supporting actor on television.

The tidy version of this story, the journeyman finally discovered in his fifties, leaves two things out. The first is how much of the late success rests on one partnership. Deacon, Shaw and now Paladin all come from Matalas, and away from him the parts of recent years have been modest: a lawyer in The Accountant 2, a three-episode turn in Apple TV+‘s The Last Thing He Told Me. The second is a writing career that ran beside the acting and mostly never reached the public. With Calero he co-created the web comic Devil Inside and developed a space-adventure pilot for Syfy, Clandestine, that did not become a series. He spent two years co-writing a Star Wars game with Amy Hennig at EA’s Visceral Games before EA shut the studio in 2017 and the project died with it. When his name finally reached players, it was as one of four credited writers on Forspoken, whose dialogue drew widespread mockery. The man Star Trek fans discovered had already spent years trying to build worlds of his own, with little to show for it on screen.

VisionQuest is the bet that the partnership travels. Matalas redeveloped Marvel’s Vision series for Disney+ after Jac Schaeffer stepped away, and Stashwick joined the cast a month after James Spader signed to return as Ultron. He plays Paladin, a mercenary Marvel introduced in the pages of Daredevil in the late 1970s and about whom, by the publisher’s own account, virtually nothing is known. Matalas has compared the character to Boba Fett and said he drew on Tommy Lee Jones‘s marshal in The Fugitive for Paladin’s slippery morality. Stashwick calls him a badass in the line of the men Matalas keeps writing for him. Diane Morgan plays his handler, and with Emily Hampshire from 12 Monkeys and Orla Brady from Picard also in the cast, the series looks like a Matalas repertory company let loose inside the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

On the Titan, Shaw spent a season outrunning a bounty hunter; on Disney+, Stashwick becomes one, hunting the white Vision that Paul Bettany first played in WandaVision.

VisionQuest premieres on Disney+ on 14 October 2026 with two of its eight episodes; the finale is due in November. Stashwick has said there is “always a chance” of a return to the Star Trek universe, though not a near one, and Matalas has spoken about wanting Shaw’s actor in any future Star Trek: Legacy. The nearer question is whether a Marvel audience, trained to cheer the hero, will do what Star Trek viewers did with Captain Shaw and side with the man blocking the road.

Featured Films

Tags: actors, Paul Bettany, VisionQuest, Terry Matalas, Todd Stashwick, 12 Monkeys

Featured News — Todd Stashwick

Analysis

Paul Bettany’s ‘Worst Avenger’ joke is VisionQuest’s best pitch

Movies

Think Like a Dog: A Heartwarming Tale of Canine Wisdom vs. Teen Angst

See all →

Related People

John Lithgow

Ray Stevenson

Trevor Eve

Tom Skerritt

Pete Davidson

Sam Pinkleton