Directors

Theo Anthony, the filmmaker who won’t trust his own camera

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Theo Anthony
Theo Anthony
Photo via The Movie Database (TMDB)
Born1989
OccupationDocumentary filmmaker
AwardsSundance Film Festival U.S. Documentary Special Jury

Most documentaries ask the audience to trust what the camera shows. Theo Anthony’s films start one step further back, with the question of who put the camera there and what it was built to see. That suspicion runs through everything he has made, from a portrait of Baltimore told through its rats to a study of the police body camera, and it explains why Darren Aronofsky has now handed him one of the hardest subjects in nonfiction: the silicon chip, an object almost nobody has looked at closely and almost everybody carries.

Aronofsky’s company Protozoa and the production outfit Memory are adapting Chris Miller’s book Chip War into a feature documentary, with Anthony directing and producing. The deal, revealed by Variety in November, put a name known mostly to festival programmers and nonfiction critics beside one of the best-known directors in American cinema. Aronofsky spoke of “the absolute original filmmaking of Theo Anthony”, and the choice makes sense once you notice how little patience Anthony has for the talking-head format that most films about technology fall back on.

Anthony, who was born in 1989, grew up in Annapolis, half an hour’s drive from the city that would become his subject. He studied creative writing and cinema at Oberlin College in Ohio, then worked as a journalist and photographer, filing reports and video from the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo for VICE and the news agency AFP. He also attended Werner Herzog‘s Rogue Film School, and the influence of Herzog, Chris Marker and Harun Farocki, the great essayists of the form, is easy to trace in what followed.

His short Chop My Money, shot in eastern Congo, premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival in 2014. A year later Filmmaker Magazine put him on its list of 25 New Faces of Independent Film, and he finished Peace in the Absence of War, a short filmed in Baltimore during the protests that followed the death of Freddie Gray in police custody. He later said those weeks showed him how narrow his view of his own backyard had been.

Rat Film, his first feature, premiered at the Locarno Film Festival in 2016. It begins with the rats in Baltimore’s alleys and the people paid to trap and poison them, and uses them as a route into the history of segregation and redlining that still shapes how the city’s neighbourhoods are served. Anthony wrote, shot and edited it himself, with a score by the Baltimore musician Dan Deacon, who became a regular collaborator. The film opened in 32 cities, aired on PBS’s Independent Lens in 2018 and was nominated at both the Gotham Awards and the Cinema Eye Honors.

Not everyone was persuaded. Slant’s Clayton Dillard wrote that the film’s “muddled interests” produced “a wildly sporadic success rate”, and the Rotten Tomatoes critics’ consensus called it artful but somewhat pretentious and heavy-handed. Anthony’s own account of the film is more uncomfortable than either verdict. He told The Fader that his first idea had been simple portraits of people who killed rats, an approach he later called “incredibly ethically problematic”, and he described himself as “this privileged white dude learning a lot about black history in Baltimore and taking some poetic license with that history.” The film, he insisted, was not the history of Baltimore but “a history of someone discovering the history of Baltimore.” That candour is the strongest argument of his work and also its exposed flank, because a filmmaker who puts his own learning on screen invites the charge that the essay is about him rather than about the people in front of the lens.

He turned next to a smaller system. Subject to Review, made for ESPN’s 30 for 30 strand and shown at the New York Film Festival in 2019, looks at Hawk-Eye, the computer-vision system that rules on line calls in professional tennis, and at the strange authority players and fans grant a machine’s replay. Anthony made it in the middle of a longer project, and the short reads now as a sketch for it.

That project was All Light, Everywhere, which premiered in the U.S. Documentary Competition at Sundance in 2021 and won a Special Jury Award for Nonfiction Experimentation. The film follows the body cameras sold to police departments by Axon, with visits to the company’s Arizona headquarters and to a Baltimore police training session, and sets them beside an aerial surveillance programme flown over the city, early astronomers’ attempts to record a solar eclipse and the shared ancestry of the movie camera and the automatic weapon. Its argument is that every image carries a point of view, including the ones marketed as neutral evidence. Super LTD, the boutique label of Neon, released it that June, and in 2025 IndieWire placed it at number 30 on its list of the best films of the decade so far.

YouTube video

Since then Anthony has worked away from the festival calendar. He spent the 2024-25 academic year as a fellow at Harvard’s Radcliffe Institute, developing a feature about Chicago’s sewer system and the strain climate change puts on it. In Hudson, the upstate New York town he now calls home, he has also served on the city council as the member for the Fourth Ward, a rare case of a documentary maker who studies civic machinery choosing to sit inside it.

Chip War is the largest canvas he has been given. According to the project’s description, the documentary will follow the vast and largely invisible supply chain that makes the chips inside phones, weapons and AI models, and the struggle between the United States and China to control it. Riel Roch-Decter produces with Anthony for Memory, alongside Aronofsky, Dylan Golden and Brendan Naylor for Protozoa, while CAA Media Finance arranged the financing and handles worldwide rights. No production schedule or release window has been announced.

Anthony began his feature career following rats through the alleys of Baltimore. His next subject is measured in nanometres, and it will be sitting, switched off, in the pocket of nearly everyone who watches the film.

Tags: , , Theo Anthony, , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.