TV Shows

Tammy Faye Bakker, the PTL Televangelist Remembered for the Mascara, Not the Mercy

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Tammy Faye Bakker
Tammy Faye Bakker
Photo via The Movie Database (TMDB)
BornMarch 7, 1942
International Falls, Minnesota, United States
DiedJuly 20, 2007 (65)
OccupationTelevangelist, gospel singer and television host
Known forThe Front Runner

For two decades the joke wrote itself. A sketch show needed only a pair of false eyelashes and a trickle of black mascara to summon Tammy Faye Bakker, and the image stuck so firmly that it outlived her ministry, her first marriage and the woman herself. What the punchline left out is the stranger record underneath: a Pentecostal preacher’s daughter who helped build one of the largest religious television operations in America, sang on it most nights, and used that pulpit to talk about addiction, sex and AIDS in ways her peers would not.

The contradiction never resolved. She was the warmest face of The PTL Club and also its most visible advertisement for the prosperity gospel, the teaching that read a lakefront house and a closet of jewellery as proof of God’s favour, and the couple’s on-air appeals for money paid for both. When the empire fell she was never charged with anything. Netflix‘s Primetime Preacher$, Joe Berlinger‘s archival documentary about her first husband and his two great rivals, has now put her back on screen, and the old question of what she knew and what she sold comes with her.

Tamara Faye LaValley was born on 7 March 1942 in International Falls, Minnesota, to two Pentecostal preachers. Their divorce soon after her birth turned her mother against ministers for a time and left the girl the eldest child of a large blended family. At North Central Bible College in Minneapolis she met a fellow student, Jim Bakker. They married on 1 April 1961, left their studies and went on the road, he preaching, she singing and playing the accordion at revival meetings.

Television found them through Pat Robertson’s Christian Broadcasting Network in Portsmouth, Virginia, where in the mid-1960s they hosted a children’s puppet show and were founding members of The 700 Club. In 1974 they set up PTL in Charlotte, North Carolina, the letters standing for Praise the Lord, and turned The PTL Club into a satellite network with a talk-show set, celebrity guests and a segment of her own, Tammy’s House Party. By the mid-1980s the Associated Press counted up to 13 million nightly viewers, and the ministry had spread off the screen into Heritage USA, a Christian theme park and hotel in Fort Mill, South Carolina.

She was the programme’s voice as much as its hostess. Between 1969 and 1996 she recorded at least sixteen gospel albums, most of them on PTL’s own label and sold through the broadcast, among them Don’t Give Up! in 1985. She cried freely on camera and flirted with her husband on air. Her friend Mel White, a minister, later explained the appeal: her fans had grown up in churches that forbade make-up and dancing, and here was a woman with dyed hair and painted lashes who took the caricature of the obedient wife and blasted it.

The broadcast for which she is now best remembered went out in 1985. By satellite she interviewed Steve Pieters, a gay minister living with AIDS, about his diagnosis, his coming out and the death of his partner, at a moment when many evangelical preachers were calling the disease a punishment. Partway through she turned to her viewers: “How sad that we as Christians, who are to be the salt of the earth, we who are supposed to be able to love everyone, are afraid so badly of an AIDS patient that we will not go up and put our arm around them and tell them that we care.” Pieters has said that strangers later told him the segment saved their lives.

The money was harder to defend. Asked about the couple’s income in 1986, she told reporters, “We don’t get what Johnny Carson makes, and we work a lot harder than him.” In March 1987 PTL came apart: the disclosure that ministry funds had been used to buy the silence of a church secretary who accused Jim Bakker of rape forced his resignation, and he admitted a sexual encounter while denying the rape. Jerry Falwell took over, and the press filled in the lifestyle, down to an air-conditioned doghouse. That same year she was reported to be in treatment for an addiction to prescription drugs. Jim was indicted in 1988 on fraud and conspiracy charges and convicted in October 1989; after the verdict she sang the hymn “On Christ the Solid Rock I Stand” to reporters through tears. His 45-year sentence was later cut to eight.

This is where the later retellings tend to lean. The 2021 film and the stage musical present a soft-hearted woman carried along by a husband’s ambition, and part of the record supports that: no prosecutor ever accused her of fraud. But she was a co-founder, a co-host and the best-known face of the lifestyle the pledges paid for, and the Carson line was no slip of the tongue; it was the ministry’s theology spoken as a grievance. Her compassion toward people with AIDS was real, and braver for the audience that heard it, but it went out from the same set as the appeals. Reading her only as the joke, or only as the saint, throws away half of the evidence.

YouTube video

She divorced Jim in 1992 while he was in prison, writing to a church in Orlando: “For years I have been pretending that everything is all right, when in fact I hurt all the time… I cannot pretend anymore.” In October 1993 she married Roe Messner, the builder who had put up much of Heritage USA; he was convicted of bankruptcy fraud in 1996 and served 27 months. That same year she was diagnosed with colon cancer, published Tammy: Telling It My Way and returned to television as co-host of The Jim J. and Tammy Faye Show with Jim J. Bullock. She played the mother of Mimi Bobeck on The Drew Carey Show, and in 2004 she joined the second season of VH1’s The Surreal Life.

The audience that kept her was not the one she had started with. Gay fans adopted her after PTL, she marched in Pride parades alongside Lady Bunny and Bruce Vilanch, and a documentary by Fenton Bailey and Randy Barbato, narrated by RuPaul and released in 2000, introduced her to people who knew only the caricature. In her last interview with Larry King she said, “When we lost everything, it was the gay people that came to my rescue, and I will always love them for that.”

Her illness played out in public. She told King in March 2004 that she had inoperable lung cancer, announced a remission that November and a relapse the following year, and let her son Jay film her treatment for his Sundance Channel series One Punk Under God. Chemotherapy stopped in May 2007. On 18 July she made a final appearance on King’s programme, saying she weighed 65 pounds, and two days later, on 20 July 2007, she died at home in Loch Lloyd, Missouri, near Kansas City, at the age of 65.

Her afterlife has been louder than most of her career. Jessica Chastain won the Academy Award for Best Actress for playing her in The Eyes of Tammy Faye, Michael Showalter’s 2021 film, with Andrew Garfield as Jim. A musical by Elton John, Jake Shears and James Graham opened at London’s Almeida Theatre in 2022, earned four Olivier nominations and then closed on Broadway in December 2024 after 29 performances. Jim Bakker died in October 2026, and weeks later Primetime Preacher$ reached Netflix with her beside him in its key art, gold microphone in hand. The archive keeps showing the same woman: one who sold the dream, and who on the same set asked a frightened audience to put an arm around the people their preachers had written off.

Tags: , , , Tammy Faye Bakker, , ,

Featured News — Tammy Faye Bakker

See all →

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.