Business

Meredith Whittaker, the Signal president at war with the AI on your phone

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Meredith Whittaker
Meredith Whittaker
Photo: Martin Kraft / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Born2000
OccupationArtificial Intelligence Researcher
AwardsHelmut Schmidt Future Prize

On Friday, Signal switched on a setting most of its users will never notice. On new iPhones the app now stops Apple‘s Siri AI from reading what is on screen inside a chat and blocks screenshots by default, and on Android it shuts the window whenever Google‘s Gemini tries to look. Meredith Whittaker, the president of Signal, announced the change herself, and in the same post she admitted it was not enough. The agents that Apple, Google and Microsoft are wiring into their operating systems can still reach what is stored on the device, and on a Mac Signal cannot stop them at all. She called it an existential threat to the app she runs.

The fight suits her, and it also exposes the bind at the center of her career. Whittaker spent more than a decade inside Google before becoming one of the sharpest critics of the business model that paid for it. Now she leads a nonprofit messenger that refuses to collect data, sells nothing and depends on donors, yet has to live on phones built by the very companies whose AI products she calls reckless. Signal can encrypt a message from end to end. It cannot encrypt the operating system.

Her route into technology was an unlikely one. Whittaker studied rhetoric and English literature at the University of California, Berkeley, and joined Google in 2006, where she stayed for thirteen years. She founded its Open Research group, which worked with academics and open-source developers on net neutrality measurement, privacy and security, and she co-founded M-Lab, the Measurement Lab, an open network that has become the largest public source of data on internet performance.

Measurement taught her to distrust claims that arrive without evidence. In 2017 she co-founded the AI Now Institute at New York University with the researcher Kate Crawford, following a symposium hosted by the White House. The institute studied what artificial intelligence does to the people it is used on rather than what it can do in a demo, and its reports kept returning to one argument: that the deeper problem was less a matter of biased code than of who owns these systems and at whom they are pointed. She later held the Minderoo Research Professorship at NYU and served as AI Now’s faculty director; today she is its chief advisor.

That argument put her on a collision course with her employer. In 2018 she wrote a petition against Project Maven, a Pentagon contract under which Google was developing machine-vision tools for the US drone program. More than three thousand employees signed it, and Google did not renew the contract. Months later she was one of the core organizers of the Google Walkout, when more than twenty thousand staff left their desks after reports that the company had paid a $90 million exit package to Andy Rubin, an executive accused of sexual misconduct. Whittaker later said Google retaliated by telling her to abandon her work at AI Now. She left in July 2019.

The same summer she told the House Science Committee that AI systems can entrench bias and asked for whistleblower protections for tech workers. Early in 2020 she went further before the House Oversight Committee, arguing that the trouble with facial recognition was not only accuracy but the power of those who deploy it on people with less, and calling for its use to stop. From November 2021 she was senior adviser on artificial intelligence to the chair of the Federal Trade Commission, Lina Khan.

Signal hired her in September 2022 as its first president, a post created with the app’s leadership. Signal carries no advertising and has no user data to sell, and Whittaker has said openly that running it costs about $50 million a year. Much of her early tenure went into explaining why a messenger that keeps almost nothing about its users still needs a large engineering team and steady donors, and why the alternative is to be paid in surveillance.

Her critics point to the limits of that model. Signal’s encryption protocol already protects WhatsApp’s conversations, yet the app itself remains a fraction of the size of the Meta product built on its cryptography, and Whittaker’s leverage over governments rests largely on one threat: that Signal will leave a country rather than weaken its encryption. She has aimed it at the European Union and, again in June, at the United Kingdom. The threat is credible because a donation-funded app has no shareholders to placate, but it also makes Signal’s answer to regulators closer to exile than to negotiation. The episode that brought the app its largest burst of attention showed a similar gap. When senior US officials were found in March 2025 to have discussed military plans in a Signal group that accidentally included a journalist, Whittaker defended the encryption as the gold standard in private communication and pointed out that no application can stop people from adding the wrong person to a chat. Publicity on that scale is hard to refuse and harder to control.

Since then her focus has shifted from governments to the companies that make the devices. At Davos in January she called operating-system AI agents perilous for encrypted services, warning that a system given root access can be hijacked. In a Bloomberg interview in June she said chatbots are not your friends and described an assistant with reach into her payment details and her Signal account as a kind of backdoor. This week, tests run by Reuters with staff from Signal and AI Now found Meta’s Muse agent reading Signal chats on Android through notification access, and Whittaker called agents with that kind of reach technologically reckless.

In 2023 TIME put her on its first list of the most influential people in artificial intelligence. In May 2024 she received the Helmut Schmidt Future Prize in Hamburg, presented by Die Zeit and its partners for work on democracy and technology, and in July 2025 she joined the board of directors of the German media group Hubert Burda Media.

What happens next depends less on Signal than on Apple, Google and Microsoft. Whittaker has asked all three for a documented way to let apps keep AI agents away from their screens and their data, and Signal says it is cautiously optimistic that Google and Apple are engaging. If they build it, the block she switched on this week becomes an industry default. If they do not, the most private messenger on the market will keep shipping workarounds against the phones it runs on, and its president will keep saying so in public.

Tags: , , , , , , , , Meredith Whittaker

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.