Sports

Jonathan Taylor, the Colts star who asked to leave, then asked to stay

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Jonathan Taylor
Jonathan Taylor
Photo: U.S. Army / Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
BornJanuary 19, 1999
Salem
OccupationFootballer
Individual awardsBert Bell Award · First-team All-Pro · Pro Bowl · NFL rushing yards leader · NFL rushing touchdowns leader · Doak Walker Award

Twice the future of Jonathan Taylor has been argued over in public, and twice the final word belonged to somebody else. The first time he wanted out, because the Colts would not pay him like the best backs in the league. The second time he wanted to stay, and the franchise that hangs his picture on its stadium set a price on him that no contender would meet. He spent one week this November saying goodbye to a city and the next week still carrying the ball for it. Being the face of a team and being one of its assets turn out to be separate jobs, and he holds both.

He comes from Salem, a small river town in southern New Jersey, and before he was a running back he was a sprinter: he won state titles in the hundred metres while setting the state record for rushing yards in a single high school season. His father, Jonathan James, had played college basketball at San Francisco State. Taylor first committed to Rutgers, the home-state school, then changed his mind and took his speed to the University of Wisconsin, a programme that builds its identity around running the ball.

Born on January 19, 1999, he needed only three seasons in Madison to rewrite the record book. His 6,174 rushing yards made him the first player in FBS history to pass 6,000 in any three-year span, and his twelve 200-yard games are still a record at that level. He won the Doak Walker Award, given to the best running back in college football, in 2018 and again in 2019, and was a unanimous All-American both years. He finished in the top ten of the Heisman Trophy vote three times without winning it, which tells you how a back without a championship contender around him tends to be judged.

Indianapolis traded up to take him with the 41st pick of the 2020 draft. He was meant to share the load with Marlon Mack, until Mack tore an Achilles tendon in the opener and the job became Taylor’s for good. He closed the regular season with 253 yards against the Jacksonville Jaguars, a franchise record for a single game, and finished his rookie year with 1,169 yards and 11 rushing touchdowns. The Colts lost a wild-card game in Buffalo that January. It remains the only playoff game of his career.

The following season was the one that made his name. He ran for 1,811 yards and 18 touchdowns in 2021, leading the NFL in both, the yardage by more than 500, scored five times in a single afternoon against the Bills and was a unanimous first-team All-Pro. He won the Bert Bell Award and finished second in the vote for Offensive Player of the Year. The Colts still missed the playoffs, beaten in the final week by a Jacksonville team that had won two games all year.

Then came the expensive part. An ankle injury cut his 2022 season to eleven games and ended it on injured reserve. In the summer of 2023, in the last year of his rookie contract and placed on the physically unable to perform list, he requested a trade after a meeting with then-owner Jim Irsay. Irsay answered in a text to a reporter: “We’re not trading Jonathan … end of discussion.” In October the two sides agreed a three-year, $42 million extension, and Taylor said what he would repeat for years: he had always wanted to retire a Colt.

He made good on the money. He ran for 1,431 yards in 2024 and returned to the Pro Bowl, then posted 1,585 yards and a league-leading 18 rushing touchdowns in 2025. The signature game came in Berlin against the Atlanta Falcons: 244 yards, three touchdowns and the winner in overtime, a run that also took him past Edgerrin James as the franchise’s career leader in rushing touchdowns.

The tidy version of this story is loyalty: the player who once asked out became the one who wanted to stay forever. The record is harder. In more than six seasons he has played one postseason game. His career carries passed 1,700 this autumn, at a position the league has spent a decade learning not to pay. The two-year, $44 million extension he signed in August, with $39 million guaranteed, made him the second-highest-paid back in football behind Bijan Robinson, yet according to CBS Sports it leaves no guaranteed money in 2027 or 2028. That makes him cheap to keep and just as easy to move. The holdout cast him as the difficult one and the farewell week cast him as the sentimental one; both readings skip the part where the number decides.

The 2026 season began with history in London, where two touchdowns in a 30-13 win over the Washington Commanders gave him six in international games, the most by any player. Then the team came apart. The Colts fired general manager Chris Ballard after a 2-4 start, traded Quenton Nelson and DeForest Buckner on the same day and kept selling. Before a 27-23 loss to the Dallas Cowboys, the stadium screens played a montage of his runs. “I love repping the horseshoe, but it’s out of our control now,” he said afterwards. “The hay is in the barn.” The New York Giants offered a second- and a fifth-round pick and then withdrew it; Indianapolis wanted the equivalent of a first-rounder, having already sent its own 2027 first to the Jets for Sauce Gardner. The deadline passed and nobody paid.

Off the field he keeps a low profile. He is married, has called his wife “my rock”, and talks about Indianapolis as the place where he grew up after college and started a family.

He was back on the field on November 15 with 83 yards on 16 carries in a 24-22 win over the Miami Dolphins that ended a five-game losing streak. It left him at 9,999 career yards from scrimmage, one short of joining Marvin Harrison, Edgerrin James, Lenny Moore and Reggie Wayne as the only Colts to reach 10,000. That yard should come early on Thursday in Houston. The larger question, whether he is still a Colt next spring, will be answered by a front office that is still being rebuilt.

Tags: , , , , , , , Jonathan Taylor

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.