Uncategorized

Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum, the director critics shrug at and Netflix keeps hiring

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum
Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum
Photo via The Movie Database (TMDB)
Born1971
Stony Brook, New York, United States
OccupationFilm and television director
Known forPurple Hearts, Aquamarine, Ramona and Beezus
AwardsEmmy

The reviews of Guarding Stars arrived on the day Netflix released it, and most of them said a version of the same thing: nobody needed another bodyguard romance, and this one works anyway. That backhanded approval has followed Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum for most of her career. She directs the kind of films critics treat as comfort viewing, from mermaid comedies to Christmas romances, and audiences watch them in numbers most prestige releases never reach. The last time one of her films became a phenomenon, it also became a political argument, and she answered it by asking viewers to meet in the middle. Her new film is a gentler proposition. The question it raises is an older one: what a director owes to the people who actually press play.

She grew up as Elizabeth Allen in Stony Brook, on the North Shore of Long Island, and went from Ward Melville High School to Cornell University, where she graduated Phi Beta Kappa. Film school came later, at the University of Southern California, where she received the Jack Nicholson Award as the strongest directing candidate of her class and was shortlisted for a Clio with a spec commercial for Coca-Cola. Her calling card was Eyeball Eddie, a dark comedy about an insecure young man with a glass eye, starring Martin Starr, Michael Rosenbaum and M. Emmet Walsh. It played Slamdance, won audience prizes at regional festivals and landed her a feature at Fox.

Born in 1971, she was in her mid-thirties when Aquamarine opened in 2006. The teen comedy, shot on location in Australia, sets Emma Roberts, the singer JoJo and Sara Paxton around a mermaid who washes into the pool of a beach club after a storm. Four years later came Ramona and Beezus, Fox’s adaptation of Beverly Cleary’s children’s books, with Joey King as the restless younger sister and Selena Gomez as the older one. It brought Rosenbaum the Women’s Image Network award for a film directed by a woman, and it remains her last feature made for a major studio’s theatrical release.

Television carried the years around it. Rosenbaum became a regular name in the credits of network drama aimed at teenagers and young adults, directing episodes of Gossip Girl and The Vampire Diaries, and later of the Netflix dark comedy Dead to Me. Her real specialty became the pilot. By her own count, every pilot she has directed and produced went to series, the Netflix figure-skating drama Spinning Out among them. The Amazon pilot of The Kicks, adapted from the soccer star Alex Morgan’s novels about a girl who joins a struggling team, earned her a Directors Guild of America nomination for children’s programs at the awards held in 2017. In the middle of that run she also made Careful What You Wish For, a Starz erotic thriller built around Nick Jonas, released in 2016.

Streaming changed the scale. Sneakerella, a Disney+ musical that turns the Cinderella story into the tale of a young sneaker designer from Queens, premiered in May 2022. Rosenbaum directed it and served as a co-executive producer, and that December it won the first Children’s and Family Emmy for outstanding fiction special, with her among the named winners; she was also nominated for its direction. Two months after Sneakerella, Netflix released Purple Hearts, in which Sofia Carson plays a struggling singer-songwriter who marries a Marine, played by Nicholas Galitzine, so that both can collect military benefits. It logged more than 102 million viewing hours in its first full week and entered Netflix’s all-time list of its most popular English-language films in seventh place, with 220.6 million hours in its first 28 days. Rosenbaum also directed the video for Carson’s song from the film, “Come Back Home”.

Its success came with a backlash that has never quite left it. Critics and viewers objected to the film’s portrait of the Marine Corps and singled out a scene in which one of the hero’s fellow Marines toasts to “hunting down some goddamn Arabs”. Vox called the film a political hate-watch, and other writers accused it of trading in racist and misogynistic stereotypes. Rosenbaum acknowledged that the script had been rewritten at the request of the US military. In an interview with Variety alongside Carson, she argued that both leads were written to be flawed and to grow, and said she hoped anyone insulted by the film would understand “that our intentions are very pure”, because people “need to start to become more moderate.” The defence describes the film she meant to make, a story of two people from opposite political camps learning to listen. It does not account for the line that travelled furthest, or for why a script that had passed through military hands should be taken as neutral ground. That gap, between what the director intended and what the audience took from the screen, is the most revealing thread in her career.

Since then Rosenbaum has kept working on both sides of the streaming divide. She directed an episode of the third season of Netflix’s Ginny & Georgia before returning to features with Guarding Stars, which Netflix released on November 18, 2026. Adapted by Erin Cardillo and Richard Keith from a novel by Katherine Center, it stars Leighton Meester as Hannah Brooks, an executive protection agent who must pose as the girlfriend of the action star Jack Stapleton, played by Jared Padalecki, at his family’s ranch in Montana, so that his ailing mother, played by Andie MacDowell, never learns about the stalker threatening him. The production shot in Calgary from December 2025 and dropped the novel’s original title to avoid confusion with the Kevin Costner and Whitney Houston film of the same name. William Bibbiani wrote in TheWrap that it “does everything it’s supposed to do and does it well”, while regretting its flat, generic Netflix look. Most reviews have praised Meester and divided over the leads’ chemistry.

Away from sets, Rosenbaum lives in Los Angeles with her husband, the writer and producer Scott Rosenbaum, and their son. She teaches at the USC film school that trained her and sits on the board of Cornell in Hollywood, the university’s alumni network in the entertainment industry.

YouTube video

The verdict that matters most to Netflix arrives every Tuesday, when the streamer publishes its weekly viewing charts. Purple Hearts taught Rosenbaum that a film can top them and still leave its director explaining what she meant. With Guarding Stars she has made a film with nothing to explain, and the first charts will show whether audiences still turn up in the same numbers when there is no argument to join.

Tags: , , , Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum, ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.