Music

Bill Evans, the jazz pianist whose restraint his own life never had

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
Bill Evans
Bill Evans
Photo: Bill_Evans,_meteorologist.jpg: Bill Evans derivative work: Off2riorob (talk) / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
BornAugust 16, 1929
Plainfield
DiedSeptember 15, 1980 (51)
OccupationJazz Pianist
AwardsGrammy Lifetime Achievement Award

On the last day of a two-week booking at the Village Vanguard, you can hear the audience on the tapes, the chatter and the clink of glasses drifting into the middle of a ballad. Bill Evans plays through it as if the room were empty. Those sets became Sunday at the Village Vanguard and Waltz for Debby, the live records jazz pianists still study bar by bar. Within days the bassist who shaped them, Scott LaFaro, was dead in a car crash, and Evans stopped playing in public for months.

That gap, between music built on restraint and a life that ran on excess, is what makes Evans so hard to write about. A film has now tried. Grant Gee’s Everybody Digs Bill Evans, which won the Silver Bear for best director at the Berlinale, follows the pianist through the months after LaFaro’s death, when he retreats to his family and does not touch a piano. His estate says it had nothing to do with it. More than four decades after his death, the argument over who gets to tell his story is still going.

The family Gee puts on screen was not an easy one. Evans grew up in North Plainfield, New Jersey, having been born in neighboring Plainfield on August 16, 1929, the younger son of Harry Evans, who ran a golf course and whose destructive behavior repeatedly drove his wife out of the house, and Mary Soroka, from a Rusyn family of coal miners. He followed his older brother, Harry, to the piano, studied at Southeastern Louisiana College on a flute scholarship and, after three years in an Army band, settled in New York in 1955, where he worked with the theorist George Russell.

His first record came almost by accident: the producer Orrin Keepnews signed him to Riverside after hearing a demo played over the telephone, and New Jazz Conceptions, recorded in 1956, introduced “Waltz for Debby”, written for his niece. In 1958 Miles Davis brought him into a sextet with John Coltrane and Cannonball Adderley. Part of the band’s mostly Black audience did not want a white pianist in the chair Red Garland had left, but Davis heard what Evans offered. “Bill had this quiet fire that I loved on piano,” he said.

Evans left the band that November, burned out and worried about his father’s health. In December, playing the introduction to Leonard Bernstein’s “Some Other Time” for a new trio album, he kept circling a one-bar figure in the left hand until it became a piece of its own, “Peace Piece”. Davis then called him back for Kind of Blue, the best-selling jazz album ever made. Evans wrote its liner notes and spent a night turning two chords Davis had scribbled on paper into “Blue in Green”. The record credited the song to Davis alone, and when Evans asked for a share of the royalties, Davis offered him a check for $25.

The trio he formed next, with LaFaro and the drummer Paul Motian, is why his name comes up whenever musicians talk about the piano trio. Evans wanted musicians “interested in each other,” and the result was a group in which the bass answered the piano instead of walking behind it. They made Portrait in Jazz and Explorations in the studio before the Vanguard engagement of June 1961. LaFaro was 25 when he died, ten days after it ended.

Evans returned that autumn with Chuck Israels on bass, but his heroin habit grew worse. He and his partner, Ellaine Schultz, were both using. In the summer of 1963 the couple moved into his parents’ house in Florida and for a time got clean. Gee’s film, adapted from Owen Martell’s novel Intermission, moves a retreat like this one into the months right after LaFaro’s death. That same year, newly signed to Verve, Evans layered up to three piano tracks on Conversations with Myself and won the first of his seven Grammy Awards.

His longest partnership began in 1966, when the Puerto Rican bassist Eddie Gómez joined for what turned into eleven years. With Jack DeJohnette on drums they recorded Bill Evans at the Montreux Jazz Festival in 1968, a second Grammy, and The Bill Evans Album, recorded in 1971, won two more. In between came duets with the guitarist Jim Hall on Undercurrent and, in 1975, The Tony Bennett/Bill Evans Album.

The standard portrait of Evans as the gentle poet of jazz piano, the touch behind Herbie Hancock and Keith Jarrett, leaves out what does not fit. His Verve catalogue is uneven, and his orchestral album with the arranger Claus Ogerman divided critics. More uncomfortable is what his inwardness cost the people around him. In 1973, playing a club in Redondo Beach, California, he fell in love with Nenette Zazzara, a part-time waitress there. When he told Schultz, his partner of twelve years, she seemed to accept it and then threw herself under a subway train. He married Zazzara that August, and their son, Evan, was born in 1975. A biography that only listens to the ballads skips that chapter.

Methadone got him off heroin in the late 1970s; cocaine took its place, eventually several grams a day. In the spring of 1979 his brother Harry, who had schizophrenia, took his own life. That August Evans recorded We Will Meet Again, its title piece written for Harry, and he gave up treatment for his hepatitis. On September 15, 1980, his drummer, Joe LaBarbera, and his companion, Laurie Verchomin, took him from his home in Fort Lee to Mount Sinai Hospital in New York, where he died that afternoon, aged 51. His friend the jazz writer Gene Lees called his addiction “the longest suicide in history.”

We Will Meet Again won a Grammy after his death, and the Recording Academy added a Lifetime Achievement Award in 1994. The vaults keep opening: in April, Elemental Music released Bill Evans at the BBC, two television sets filmed in London in 1965, produced by Zev Feldman in cooperation with the estate. That cooperation is the contrast with the film. In September the estate said Everybody Digs Bill Evans had been made without its endorsement or participation and that the family had not seen it, while adding that it was looking forward to doing so.

Gee’s film, with Anders Danielsen Lie as Evans and Bill Pullman and Laurie Metcalf as his parents, opened in the UK in September and reaches Spain on November 27, France on December 9 and US cinemas on January 8, 2027. Its title borrows the name of the 1958 record on which “Peace Piece” first appeared, one left-hand figure repeated for more than six minutes while the right hand wanders above it. It remains the clearest case Evans made for restraint; the film asks audiences to hear it against the life around it.

Selected Recordings

  • New Jazz Conceptions (1957)
  • Know What I Mean? (1961)
  • Empathy (1962)
  • Interplay (1962)
  • Undercurrent (1962)
  • Conversations With Myself (1963)
  • Trio 64 (1964)
  • Alone (1969)
  • The Tony Bennett / Bill Evans Album (1975)
  • On Green Dolphin Street (1977)
  • Quintessence (1977)
  • Autumn Leaves = 枯葉 (1979)

Tags: , , Bill Evans, , ,

Featured News — Bill Evans

See all →

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.