Movies

Tsukamoto turns a Black Marine’s Vietnam guilt into raw body-horror in Mr. Nelson

Martha Lucas

Shinya Tsukamoto built his name on flesh and metal, and he has now aimed that unblinking camera at a harder subject: what an American Marine did in Vietnam, and what it did to him. Mr. Nelson, Did You Kill People? takes the memoir of a Black soldier turned peace activist and runs it through the director’s signature register of physical dread, asking whether one man can be both the victim and the author of the same war.

The film follows Allen Nelson, played by Rodney Hicks, who enlists at eighteen to escape poverty and racism at home and finds in combat only one lesson worth mastering: how many people he can kill. The wage for that skill turns out to be a fistful of pay and a lifetime of post-traumatic stress. Thrown out of his home and left on the street, Nelson is pulled back from the edge by a Veterans Affairs doctor who refuses to let him vanish.

YouTube video

Tsukamoto works the way he almost always has, as a near one-man crew who writes, directs, shoots and edits the picture himself. That method produced the clanging body-horror of Tetsuo, and it lends this project the same handmade intensity, all sweat and grain and faces pushed too close to the lens. It is only his second English-language feature, after Tetsuo: The Bullet Man, and he assembled it across shoots in New York City, Okinawa, Vietnam and Japan, a geography that mirrors the reach of the story itself.

Geoffrey Rush plays Dr. Daniels, the counselor whose patience becomes Nelson’s lifeline and who gives the film its calmest, most conventional scenes. Rodney Hicks, who came up on the New York stage and originated a role in the first Broadway run of Rent, carries the older Nelson, while Mark Merphy plays the soldier as a young man. Tatyana Ali appears as Linda Nelson, and Tsukamoto regular Lily Franky turns up as Kuroi. The casting reaches deliberately across the Pacific, matching a Japanese filmmaker to a distinctly American wound.

The pairing is less strange than it looks. The real Allen Nelson spent his later years touring Japan and Okinawa to speak about war and conscience, which is how his testimony first reached a director who has spent much of his career circling the same territory. The film stands alongside Tsukamoto’s earlier war cinema as another attempt to shoot combat without glory, closing an informal trilogy he has made largely by hand and on his own terms.

On screen the movie splits cleanly in two. The Vietnam passages are the strongest, wordless stretches of slaughter and fear where the camera tracks individual faces through the chaos rather than staging spectacle. The second half trades the jungle for the slow labor of recovery, the therapy sessions and the long climb back toward something like peace. At 116 minutes, the two modes are asked to share one film, and they do not always speak the same language.

That split is also the film’s biggest liability. Early reviews out of the festival circuit describe two movies fighting for control, one a study of a soldier trapped by circumstance, the other a reckoning with a man who committed atrocities. Several critics questioned whether the picture ever reconciles them, and whether its pull toward redemption crowds out the Vietnamese lives its hero helped to end. A late sequence of communal forgiveness read to more than one writer as sentiment reaching for an award rather than an honest accounting. The film, tellingly, never quite answers the blunt question of its own title.

What it does not settle is whether a redemption arc can hold a perpetrator to account at all, or whether the form itself lets Nelson off the hook. The Vietnamese remain largely a backdrop to an American recovery, and the movie’s compassion flows in one direction. Those are not small reservations for a work that asks to be taken as a moral inquiry, and they will follow the film wherever it screens.

Rodney Hicks as Allen Nelson in the Shinya Tsukamoto war drama Mr. Nelson Did You Kill People (2026)
Rodney Hicks in Mr. Nelson, Did You Kill People? (2026)

None of that dimmed its festival run. Mr. Nelson, Did You Kill People? premiered in competition at the Venice International Film Festival and left with the Leoncino d’Oro, the young jury’s prize, before traveling to Toronto as a Special Presentation for its North American bow. Produced by Kino Films with Kinoshita Group, Cross Media International and Vietnam’s Chanh Phuong Films, it arrives with festival credibility but no guarantee of a wide release. Whether that momentum converts into international distribution is still an open question, and no United States theatrical date has been confirmed.

For now the clearest date on the calendar belongs to Japan, where Kino Films opens the picture in theaters on September 11, 2026. Audiences elsewhere will have to wait for distributors to decide how to handle a war film that offers no easy comfort and, by its own design, no clean answer.

Cast

Photos: The Movie Database (TMDB)

Tags: , , , , , ,

Discussion

There are 0 comments.