Lizzy Caplan, the scene-stealer who finally got a film of her own and spent it on the floor

Lizzy Caplan

Photo: Montclair Film / CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Born	June 30, 1982 Los Angeles, California, United States
Occupation	Actress
Known for	Mean Girls, 127 Hours, Now You See Me 2
Awards	2 Critics' Choice · 4 Emmy (nomination)

For most of her career, Lizzy Caplan has been the person a story leans on without being named after. Janis Ian is not the lead of Mean Girls, yet she carries the film’s best jokes and its longest grudge. Virginia Johnson shares the research in Masters of Sex with a man whose name sits first on the title card and on the books. Libby Epstein enters Fleishman Is in Trouble as a narrator standing at the edge of somebody else’s divorce and leaves it as the series’ real subject. The pattern is too consistent to be luck. Caplan keeps choosing the woman who sees the whole room, and the room keeps taking a while to look back.

That is what makes Drag such a strange reward. The first film built entirely around her physical performance asks her to spend most of its running time unable to move: a small-time burglar who throws out her back halfway through a break-in and has to be hauled, step by excruciating step, out of a stranger’s house. After two decades of stealing scenes from the corner of the frame, she finally has the centre of one, and she plays it from the floor.

Elizabeth Anne Caplan grew up in the Miracle Mile district of Los Angeles, the city where she was born on June 30, 1982, as the youngest of three children in a Reform Jewish household. Her father, Richard, was a lawyer. Her mother, Barbara, worked as a political aide, and her uncle, Howard Bragman, became one of the best-known publicists in town. Her mother died of cancer when Caplan was thirteen, a loss that arrived just as she was discovering what she wanted to do.

At Alexander Hamilton High School she joined the Academy of Music to study piano, then moved over to drama, and played on the school soccer team on the side. She graduated in 2000 and skipped college. By then she already had a credit that would age better than almost anything else on television that season: Sara, the girl who ends up dating Jason Segel‘s Nick in Freaks and Geeks, the NBC series that lasted a single season and became a reference point long after its cancellation.

Then came Mean Girls. Tina Fey‘s script handed Janis Ian the sharpest lines and the revenge plot that sets the story in motion, and Caplan, twenty-one when the film opened in 2004, played her as the one student who had seen through the cafeteria hierarchy before the first scene. By plot mechanics it was a supporting part. By the length of time audiences have kept quoting it, it was the role that defined her for a decade.

The years that followed ran against the usual logic of a breakout. Related on The WB lasted one season, and so did The Class on CBS, an ensemble sitcom about grown-up schoolmates in which she played Kat Warbler. In Cloverfield she was Marlena Diamond, the dry-witted stranger who walks into a Manhattan party just before a monster walks into the city, and the performance brought her a Saturn Award nomination. She turned up as Amy Burley in HBO’s True Blood. On Starz she played Casey, the stand-up comedian working catering shifts in Party Down, a comedy that drew small ratings, ended after two seasons and built a devoted audience mostly after it was gone.

Around those series came a run of film parts that used her for precision rather than volume: Aron Ralston’s sister in Danny Boyle’s 127 Hours, a place in the ensemble of Hot Tub Time Machine, one of the three bridesmaids behaving badly in Bachelorette alongside Kirsten Dunst and Isla Fisher, and Agent Lacey, the CIA officer who recruits Seth Rogen and James Franco for an assassination plot in The Interview. She also had a stretch on Fox’s New Girl. Variety had named her one of its ten actors to watch back in 2006. For several years, watching was mostly what the industry did.

Masters of Sex changed the scale. Showtime’s drama about the research partnership of William Masters and Virginia Johnson cast Caplan as Johnson before it had signed Michael Sheen to play Masters, and she turned down other offers during the months it took to close the deal. To prepare, she read Thomas Maier’s biography of the pair and listened to tapes of his interviews with Johnson. She hoped to spend time with the real woman, but Johnson was ambivalent about the series and died in 2013, the year it premiered. Caplan, playing a real person for the first time, said she felt a “deep responsibility” toward her. Over four seasons she played a single mother without a university degree who became co-author of Human Sexual Response, and she even recorded her own version of “You Don’t Know Me” for one episode.

It is hard to miss the irony in how the show was received. A series about a woman whose contribution had long been filed under a man’s name was often sold, and discussed, through its premise and its male lead, while its most layered performance was treated as the partner role. The awards record tells the same story: Caplan earned a Primetime Emmy nomination for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series in 2014, along with Critics’ Choice and Satellite nominations, and did not win any of them. Showtime ended the series after its fourth season in 2016. The work has aged better than the trophies suggest, and the gap between how highly she was rated and how rarely she was rewarded remains the most accurate summary of that phase of her career.

What followed looked scattered from the outside and consistent from the inside. She returned to the screen as Lula, the illusionist, in Now You See Me 2, played Brad Pitt‘s sister in Robert Zemeckis‘s Allied and joined Sky’s Das Boot series as Carla Monroe. In the second season of Hulu’s Castle Rock she played a younger Annie Wilkes, the nurse from Stephen King‘s Misery, inviting a comparison with Kathy Bates’s Oscar-winning performance that few actors would have volunteered for. In Apple TV+’s Truth Be Told she played identical twin sisters opposite Octavia Spencer, and in Netflix’s animated Inside Job she voiced Reagan Ridley, a brilliant and socially hopeless scientist working inside a company that runs the world’s conspiracies.

The second major arrival came with Fleishman Is in Trouble, the FX on Hulu adaptation of Taffy Brodesser-Akner’s novel, which the author adapted for the screen herself. Caplan played Libby Epstein, a former magazine writer turned suburban mother who narrates the divorce of her college friend Toby, played by Jesse Eisenberg, and slowly lets slip that her own restlessness is the story’s true subject. The part brought her a second Emmy nomination, this time for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie in 2023. Its shooting schedule also kept her out of the Party Down revival that year, until the producers found a free weekend and slipped Casey into the season finale’s mid-credits scene.

She followed it with two reworkings of familiar material at very different temperatures. In Paramount+’s Fatal Attraction series she took on Alex Forrest, the character Glenn Close defined in 1987, opposite Joshua Jackson. In the horror film Cobweb she played Carol, the mother of a boy who hears knocking from inside the walls of the family home. In both cases she chose the woman an audience is primed to fear and played her as someone with reasons.

In February 2025, Netflix released Zero Day, a six-episode political thriller in which she played Alexandra Mullen, a congresswoman and the daughter of the former president played by Robert De Niro, the two often at odds on screen. Reviews of the series were mixed, and several critics felt the script never explored her character’s conflict of interest, yet more than one notice singled out Caplan and De Niro as its strongest element. That November she returned as Lula in Now You See Me: Now You Don’t, the third film in the illusionist franchise.

Drag premiered as a Midnight selection at SXSW on March 13, 2026. Written and directed by Raviv Ullman and Greg Yagolnitzer, and produced by Danny, Lucy and Jake DeVito, it casts Caplan as a petty thief whose back gives out mid-heist in a remote house in upstate New York, with Lucy DeVito as the sister she calls in from the getaway car and John Stamos in a role that reviewers advised audiences to discover for themselves. Dread Central argued that with a different lead the premise could easily have tipped into slapstick, and that Caplan keeps the pain real enough for the comedy to grow out of it. Briarcliff Entertainment acquired the film in May, and its theatrical release in the United States is set for January 29, 2027.

Television is filling the rest of her calendar. Apple TV cast her in the fifth season of The Morning Show as Gwen, a passionate and uncompromising Broadway theatre director. In June she joined Far Cry, the FX anthology series that Noah Hawley and Rob Mac are building from the Ubisoft games, in a role that has not been disclosed; production began in Spain in September, with Steve Buscemi, Brendan Gleeson and Jennifer Jason Leigh among the cast. She is also part of Peter Morgan’s five-part Netflix adaptation of The Boys from Brazil, playing Hannah Liebermann opposite Jeremy Strong’s Nazi hunter Yakov Liebermann, a production that filmed in Germany through the winter. In September, Disney+ ordered a Darkwing Duck revival with Caplan voicing an older Gosalyn opposite Mark Hamill and Seth Rogen, and she has gone back to American Dad! as Debbie, a voice role she first played twenty years ago.

Caplan met the English actor Tom Riley in London in January 2015, while she was filming Now You See Me 2. They made their first red-carpet appearance as a couple at the Prague Opera Ball the following year, became engaged in New York in May 2016 and married in September 2017 in Ravello, on Italy’s Amalfi Coast. Their son was born in 2021.

At forty-four, she has the lead in a film that opens in January and a place in four series in various stages of production. The new roles still rhyme with the old ones: the director who refuses to compromise, the woman beside the Nazi hunter, the daughter of a hero who has outlived his usefulness. What has changed is the order of events. The work is now being cast around her rather than discovered after the fact, and the release of Drag will test whether a long reputation as the sharpest person in the room can carry a film by itself.

Featured Films

Tags: actors, actresses, Jesse Eisenberg, Mean Girls, Lizzy Caplan, Masters of Sex, Michael Sheen

Featured News — Lizzy Caplan

Movies

Cobweb: the Lizzy Caplan horror movie where the knocking comes from inside the wall

Series

‘Fatal Attraction’ (2023) A Paramount+ Series Starring Joshua Jackson and Lizzy Caplan

See all →

Related People

Tina Fey

Lily Gladstone

Caitlin FitzGerald

Olivia Wilde

Olivia Colman

Lily James