Movies

James Baldwin: “…such mortal danger that I had fled, all the way around the corner, to France”

Camille Lefèvre

There is a moment, late in Yashaddai Owens’s Jimmy, when the film stops conjuring James Baldwin and simply lets him talk. For most of its running time this black-and-white reverie keeps the writer wordless — a young man adrift in a Paris of halation and jazz, freedom rendered as texture rather than argument. Then a voice reads from Baldwin himself, and the seductive mood cracks open.

“My history in the West had, for its daily effect, placed me in such mortal danger that I had fled, all the way around the corner, to France,”

The line is drawn from No Name in the Street, Baldwin’s later reckoning, and in the film it arrives spoken aloud — the specifics coming, at last, to name what Owens’s images have only breathed. The effect is corrective. Everything before it has framed the crossing as liberation: the rush of a gay Black man loosed from American categories, in love with a stranger and with the city itself. The sentence refuses that romance. Baldwin does not say he chose Paris; he says he fled. He does not say freedom; he says mortal danger.

This is where Owens’s beautiful film argues against itself, and where its honesty lives. Shot on 16mm with the dreamy glow of the New Wave and cut to bebop, Jimmy is engineered to seduce — a city symphony with Baldwin at its center. But the auteur has smuggled in the counter-argument: the same voice that could sell exile as an escape insists that exile was survival. It is the phrase “all the way around the corner” that stings. It shrinks the Atlantic to a sidestep, as if the danger were still visible from the doorway he ran through — because, for Baldwin, it always was. France was never elsewhere; it was the nearest place the terror had not yet reached.

Baldwin was never sentimental about his own departure, and that is the track record the film honors when it finally quotes him. The essays that made him kept naming the thing a mood piece would rather dissolve into atmosphere: that the flight was forced, and that the alienation crossed the water with him. Variety’s review lands on the same paradox, reading the film not as a great escape but as a renewed confrontation. The quote is its proof text.

Owens spends an hour making Paris look like deliverance, then hands Baldwin a single sentence to explain that deliverance is not the word for it. It is the most Baldwinian gesture in the film: the beauty is real, and it is not the point. The danger was always just around the corner.

Tags: , , , ,

Discussion

There are 0 comments.