Business

Trader Kevin Muir buys Treasurys as the Fed tightens into a slowing economy

The 10-year Treasury yield has closed above 5% for four straight sessions as futures price more Fed hikes, and the MacroTourist author argues that tightening into a slowdown sets up the next bond rally
Victor Maslow
Add us on Google

For most of this year, owning long-dated US government bonds has been a slow way to lose money. Kevin Muir, the trader who writes The MacroTourist newsletter, has decided to start buying Treasurys at the moment the Federal Reserve sounds most determined to keep hurting bondholders. His argument, reported by MarketWatch, cuts against the instinct of most investors: a central bank that keeps raising rates while the economy loses steam is setting up the bond rally, not postponing it.

Muir is no bond evangelist. He spent the autumn waiting for conditions to look truly bleak before committing, then watched Treasurys rally without him. The sell-off of the past week handed him a second chance, and he thanked one Fed governor by name for providing it.

Waller handed a bond skeptic his second chance

At the end of September, Muir told his readers it was not yet time to own fixed income. Yields kept climbing into October, and the 10-year Treasury yield closed at 5.31% early that month, its highest close since 2002. When bonds turned and rallied from mid-October, he was still on the sidelines.

Then Fed Governor Christopher Waller reopened the door. Speaking in London last week, Waller said he would consider a half-point rate hike in December if core inflation kept running at 0.3% a month or more, warning that “hiking only 25 basis points would put our credibility at risk,” CNN reported. Core prices rose 0.3% in October against the 0.2% economists expected, and the two-year yield posted its biggest one-day jump since April 2025. Muir’s latest letter is titled “Missed the Cover, Caught the Hike,” and its subtitle thanks Waller for the opening.

The bet is that the Fed tightens until something breaks

The trade rests on an old pattern in rates markets. A central bank that tightens into weakness tends to overshoot, growth cracks, and long-term yields fall as investors start pricing the cuts that follow. Muir argued earlier this month that the economy is not as strong as its headline jobs numbers suggest, and the housing market supports him: US home sales have fallen to a 16-year low as owners borrow against their houses rather than sell, as Martin Cid Magazine reported last week. With the 30-year fixed mortgage averaging 7.48%, according to 24/7 Wall St., few households can afford to move.

The entry price also helps. A buyer who locks in a 10-year yield above 5% collects income that US bonds had not offered for most of the past two decades, which gives some cushion if prices keep falling for a while.

Why the trade can hurt before it pays

The Fed has not finished. On Wednesday, Waller went further in a live CNBC interview, saying a half-point increase is probably necessary in December, that the Fed needs to reverse the three quarter-point cuts it made last year and may need to do more. “You might need to, like, shock people,” he said, adding that inflation is “headed in the wrong direction, and it’s spreading out.” Futures fully price a quarter-point hike in December and another in January, according to CME Group’s FedWatch tool cited by CNBC. Santander’s chief US economist Stephen Stanley has said a half-point move likely does not reflect the consensus among Fed officials.

Bonds have also failed at their usual job. When AI stocks sold off this autumn, investors did not run to Treasurys, so mixed stock-and-bond portfolios got no cushion. The iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF is down about 35% over five years. The stakes travel well beyond Wall Street: US yields set a floor for borrowing costs from European mortgages to emerging-market corporate debt, so a turn in Treasurys would lower the price of money far outside the United States.

The next tests arrive this week

The 10-year yield closed at 5.10% on Tuesday, its fourth straight session above 5%, and 2026 now counts 27 closes above that line against 29 in 2007, according to Treasury data compiled by 24/7 Wall St. The two-year yield rose to 4.83% after Waller spoke on Wednesday. The Treasury sells $16 billion of 20-year bonds on Wednesday, after October’s sale cleared at 5.469%, and the Fed releases the minutes of its October meeting the same afternoon. The upper bound of the federal funds rate stands at 4.00% ahead of the Federal Open Market Committee meeting on December 8 and 9.

Muir missed the first rally because he wanted the news to look worse. Waller has spent a week promising that it will.

Tags: , , , , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.