Authors

James Baldwin, the novelist who wrote Giovanni’s Room and would not be anyone’s spokesman

Penelope H. Fritz
Add us on Google
James Baldwin
James Baldwin
Photo: Allan warren / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
BornAugust 2, 1924
Harlem, New York City, United States
DiedDecember 1, 1987 (63)
OccupationWriter
Known forI Am Not Your Negro, Public Speaking, Meeting the Man: James Baldwin in Paris
AwardsRosenwald Fellowship · Guggenheim Fellowship · George Polk Memorial · Langston Hughes Medal · Commandeur de la Légion d'honneur

The literary biography people argued about most this past year does not open at a lectern or on a march. Nicholas Boggs built Baldwin: A Love Story around four of James Baldwin’s most intimate relationships, and the book has since reached the shortlist of Britain’s leading nonfiction prize and a film deal, with Boggs writing the screenplay alongside the novelist Marlon James. It is an odd sort of rescue. Baldwin spent the second half of his life insisting that he was a writer and not a spokesman, and for decades the culture kept filing him under the second word.

Read the novels and that argument is easy to see. His characters are men who cannot say what they want, and who leave the room at the decisive moment rather than say it. The essays work differently. They address white America in the first person plural and then, a paragraph later, turn on it, in sentences that the critic Darryl Pinckney described as a meeting of Henry James, the Bible and Harlem.

His mother, Emma Berdis Jones, had come north from Deal Island, Maryland, and never told her son who his father was. She gave birth to him at Harlem Hospital on 2 August 1924 and three years later married David Baldwin, a Baptist preacher from Louisiana whose surname the boy took and whose contempt for books he never escaped. The eldest of nine children, James was preaching his own sermons at Fireside Pentecostal Assembly by the age of 14. At Frederick Douglass Junior High his French teacher was the Harlem Renaissance poet Countee Cullen; at De Witt Clinton High School in the Bronx he worked on the literary magazine with a classmate named Richard Avedon and wrote “novelist-playwright” under his ambitions in the yearbook.

David Baldwin died in 1943, on the day his last child was born. The funeral fell on James’s nineteenth birthday, as the Harlem riot broke out, and he would turn that week into the title essay of Notes of a Native Son. In Greenwich Village the painter Beauford Delaney showed him that a Black man could live from art, and Richard Wright read an early draft of his first novel. In November 1948 Baldwin flew to Paris on a Rosenwald Fellowship with forty dollars in his pocket.

Paris gave him distance and nine years of hotel rooms in Saint-Germain. He used them to break with Wright in print, attacking the protest novel in “Everybody’s Protest Novel”, and to finish the book he had started at 17. Go Tell It on the Mountain, published by Knopf in 1953, follows the Harlem boy John Grimes onto the threshing floor of a storefront church and into the history of the family that made him; Time later placed it among the hundred best English-language novels. Two years later his school friend Sol Stein talked him into a collection. Baldwin protested that he was too young to publish his memoirs, then delivered Notes of a Native Son.

Then, in 1956, he swerved. Giovanni’s Room is narrated by David, a white American in Paris whose fiancée is away in Spain, and it follows his affair with an Italian bartender to a guillotine. Readers who expected another novel about Black Harlem got a book with almost no Black characters and an explicitly homoerotic subject. The controversy was loud, though the reviews were kind, and the novel has been passed from one queer reader to the next ever since.

He went home in 1957 and was soon reporting from the segregated South. Another Country, finished in Istanbul and published in 1962, tangled Black and white, gay and straight lovers in one sprawling New York cast. Then came The Fire Next Time, the 1963 book built around a long essay first printed in The New Yorker, which put him on the cover of Time. In February 1965 he faced William F. Buckley Jr. at the Cambridge Union, and the students voted overwhelmingly for Baldwin.

Fame cost him the critics. Black nationalists dismissed his insistence on love as a political force, and Eldridge Cleaver attacked him viciously in Soul on Ice. From Saint-Paul-de-Vence, where he settled in 1970, he wrote If Beale Street Could Talk and Just Above My Head, novels about Black families holding together, and reviewers largely shrugged. He never won a National Book Award or a Pulitzer, a neglect that 48 Black writers and critics cited weeks after his death in a public statement defending Toni Morrison’s Beloved. Even the current revival has its dissenters: Commonweal faulted Boggs for leaning on the love story to explain away Baldwin’s more questionable behaviour.

YouTube video

In Provence the house stayed open to visiting friends, from Nina Simone to Miles Davis, and France made him a commander of the Légion d’honneur in 1986. He died of stomach cancer there on 1 December 1987, leaving unfinished a memoir about Medgar Evers, Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. Morrison, who had once lived in his New York apartment building, wrote his eulogy for The New York Times. The house itself was demolished, and apartments now stand on the site.

His unfinished manuscript, Remember This House, became Raoul Peck’s I Am Not Your Negro, which won the BAFTA for best documentary, and in 2018 Barry Jenkins brought If Beale Street Could Talk to the screen. The Boggs adaptation, still without a director or cast, would be the first major film about the man himself. What the books argued, and keep arguing, is the thing his admirers and critics both found hardest to accept: that the private life was never a distraction from the public one, because for Baldwin the two were always the same subject.

Tags: , , James Baldwin, , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.