Analysis

David Bates, the defender Clarke never picked again, is back in the Scotland squad

Molly Se-kyung
Add us on Google

David Bates is back in the Scotland squad after seven years away, and the coverage has reached for the same word. The Scotsman called it a shock call-up. The Glasgow Times went with an ex-Rangers star back after years away. The BBC kept it flatter: a Turkey-based centre-back replacing the withdrawn Luis Binks for the Nations League games against North Macedonia and Switzerland.

The shock is real, but it belongs to the old regime, not to the player. Bates never vanished. He spent the years since his last cap in top-flight football in Belgium and now Turkey, where he has started every league game for a promoted side near the top of the table. What changed is the person reading the list. Sebastien Pocognoli says he arrived without a fixed view of the past, and Bates is the plainest test yet of whether he meant it. This recall is a correction, not a gamble. The only open question is whether Pocognoli puts him on the pitch.

That matters beyond one defender. A national team that judges players on where they are now, rather than on where a previous staff left them, changes the calculation for every Scottish footballer working in a league far from Scottish attention.

How David Bates fell out of the Scotland picture

Bates’ international career came early and ended fast. He made his debut under Alex McLeish in a 4-0 win over Albania in November 2018, according to The Scotsman, and won his second cap three days later in a 3-2 win over Israel. He also played in the 3-0 defeat in Kazakhstan, which the paper calls infamous, and in a 2-0 win over San Marino. McLeish was sacked the following month. The BBC notes that all four caps came while Bates was at Hamburg, where Bundesliga.com once profiled him as the “Ginger Ramos”.

Steve Clarke brought him back once, in September 2019, as late injury cover. Bates sat on the bench, unused, for home defeats by Russia and Belgium. The Scotsman sums up what followed in one line: Clarke never selected him again before resigning after the 2026 World Cup.

His club career did not stall. It moved out of Scottish sight. After Hamburg came loans at Sheffield Wednesday and Cercle Brugge, a single season at Aberdeen and then four seasons in Belgium, two at Mechelen and two at Standard Liège. The BBC says Mechelen is where he made most of his career appearances. Standard sold him to Amedspor in the summer for £420,000, The Scotsman reports, and Habertürk reported a two-year deal with an option for a third. He has started all 11 league matches for the newly promoted side, who sit third.

What Sebastien Pocognoli said about Clarke’s Scotland

Pocognoli, the former Monaco coach who led Union Saint-Gilloise to their first Belgian title in 39 years, took over after Clarke stepped down. At his unveiling he promised to keep the heritage built under his predecessor while bringing new ideas, and he set out the terms, in remarks reported by The Irish News: “It doesn’t matter where you play or who you are, you have to show the desire and fit the philosophy that I want to bring on the pitch.”

His first squad showed what that meant. The Scotsman counted that exactly half of the 28 players named had not been involved at the World Cup, and that the average age had dropped to 26 from nearly 29. It also brought back Oli McBurnie, last capped in 2021. Asked about that recall, Pocognoli told the Daily Record, as quoted by the Yorkshire Post, that he “did not have any fixed perception about what had happened in the past”. He called it “a fresh start for everybody”.

Ryan Porteous came next. The BBC framed his return as a road from Dalkeith to Los Angeles that had paid off; the Los Angeles FC defender came in last week when Stephen Welsh dropped out, according to The Scotsman. Now Bates replaces Binks. That makes three recalls since September of players who had been outside the picture, each justified by current form rather than old reputation.

Bates saw the logic coming. In an October interview with Record Sport, relayed by Brit Brief, he said: “It’s a good squad but he’s a Belgian coach so he’ll know the Belgian league really well. Hopefully he knows my face and I can get into future squads.” He added that his father kept messaging him to ask whether he would get back in. At Amedspor he plays for Besnik Hasi, his former coach at Mechelen, according to the same interview. This was a player who had worked out which coach would have watched him.

The case that David Bates is only emergency cover

There is a strong case against reading much into any of this, and it deserves a fair statement. Bates was not in the squad Pocognoli named in early November. Nine defenders were, and Scott McKenna had already been ruled out with a back strain. The Scotsman’s preview the day before suggested Porteous or Wrexham’s Dom Hyam as possible replacements. Bates arrived only after two withdrawals, Welsh and then Binks, whose reason The Scotsman describes as an unspecified issue. On that reading he is simply the next name on a depth chart.

The rest of the counter-argument follows from there. Pocognoli’s project is built on youth, and at 30 Bates runs against it. Eleven league games for a promoted Turkish club is a small sample. His caps belong to the McLeish era, which ended with that defeat in Kazakhstan. And Clarke’s choices were not arbitrary: his teams qualified for three major tournaments, the record The Irish News placed at the centre of Pocognoli’s inheritance. A coach who respects that record might reasonably treat its omissions as informed judgments too.

Why the David Bates recall is still a correction

Every one of those points is accurate, and none of them changes the central fact. When Pocognoli needed a centre-back at short notice, he did not take the alternative name the preview had floated. He went to a player the previous staff had stopped picking after one unused week on the bench, and he did it on the strength of what that player is doing now. That is the McBurnie principle again, applied to a defender.

The age objection cuts both ways. The BBC lists Luke Graham, Jack Hendry and Porteous as the other central defenders, with Kieran Tierney able to drop into the back three Pocognoli prefers. A group that young has room for a defender who has started every game of his season. On squad day, before any withdrawal, Scott McDermott, one of the pundits in a panel relayed by Brit Brief, had already asked for Bates to get a chance on his form in Turkey. The call was a shock to headline writers. At least one person watching his matches had asked for it.

The Kazakhstan argument is stranger still. Bates was 22 that night. The defender Pocognoli has picked is 30, with more than 100 league games in Belgium by Wikipedia’s count and a season of starts in Turkey. Scotland did not forget David Bates. It stopped looking.

What the recall means for Scotland’s next two games

The stakes are modest, which is why the call makes sense. North Macedonia come to Hampden on Friday with no points in the group, according to the BBC, while Switzerland, who host Scotland on Monday in St Gallen, have won every game. Slovenia sit three points above Scotland, and the Brit Brief preview noted that Scotland would need four points from the two games to have any chance of catching them for second place.

A home game against a side without a point is the obvious place to look at a recalled defender. If Bates plays, he earns the first cap of his second Scotland career against the right opponent. If he does not, the recall still says something: the door Clarke closed is open again, and the next Scot playing in Belgium, Denmark or Turkey can expect a head coach who watches those leagues to notice.

David Bates and Scotland: the record, and the guesswork

Confirmed: David Bates, born in Kirkcaldy, has four Scotland caps, all won under McLeish in 2018 and 2019, and replaces Luis Binks for the Nations League games against North Macedonia and Switzerland, according to the BBC and The Scotsman. Clarke last called him up in September 2019 and did not use him. He joined Amedspor from Standard Liège in the summer for £420,000, The Scotsman reports, and has started all 11 league matches.

Still guesswork, after one correction: the Glasgow Times wrote that Bates made his Scotland debut under Pocognoli, but the record says McLeish, in November 2018. No outlet has reported whether Pocognoli will play him, or why Binks withdrew beyond what The Scotsman calls an unspecified issue. And nothing Pocognoli has said ties the call to Belgium. For now, that connection is a hope Bates said out loud in October.

Tags: , , , , ,

Add us on Google

Discussion

There are 0 comments.